THE Great Grading Results Thread

Update:

Ok, sub was a fluke, thankfully. Was worrying that I needed glasses or something lol. Had ~70 more cards finish up after that, and the grades were pretty normal. Most of it was non-holo junk to resell (like those Delta Species Dittos that randomly became super valuable), but got a handful of nice cards to keep, too:


There were, of course, a few disappointments. Luckily nothing too crazy. But one that I find really funny:

I opened this in the literal same pack as this Swampert:

Brutal lol

16 Likes

Beauts!!

Zorloth, you seem to be our resident CGC enthusiast, so I’m curious to hear your thoughts on their grading standards vs the alternatives.

2 Likes

My view of CGC is more or less encapsulated by this (extremely famous) Churchill quote:

“Many forms of Government have been tried, and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.…”

CGC is the worst grading company…except for all the others. Basically, CGC is deeply flawed, but no more so than the other options.

What I like the most about CGC is the plastic case itself. That part of the product is basically perfect. And that’s a really big deal for someone like me who enjoys looking at my cards very closely.

What I don’t like about CGC are the same things that I don’t like about other grading companies–namely that they’re just not very good at their job lol.

Basically, like other grading companies, they don’t have standards that they apply consistently or replicably. You have to buy the card, not the grade.

12 Likes

PSA too hard on vintage imo

6 Likes

That said I did have a bunch of goodies. Here’s a snip, 2 of my favs

9 Likes

For both of those to get 8’s…that’s pretty brutal.

2 Likes

Never in my life would I have expected a PSA 9 on this card. Have had this for close to 20 years when I picked a couple of copies up at a Pokemon event in Italy. Pop 1 of 2 in this grade with none graded higher. Very happy. Need to speak to PSA about the label as this wasn’t a Journey Across America event.

15 Likes

I mean it did go from Italy to the US so they’re not wrong…..

1 Like

Anyone else ever get a “Your order is on hold There is a problem with your order Contact support” it’s in research and ID. I did write in Umbreon poke ball terastal festival because it wouldn’t pop up for a card

Lmao - yeah I guess this card specifically went on a journey across America.

3 Likes

Had this a few times, typically they’ll email you first.

Feels nice to get a vintage 10 from an eBay buy in this day and age.

18 Likes

After four months of waiting, this is the result. Thank you, CGC

11 Likes

Wait what’s the back story on this lol

2 Likes

Research mode?

Ladies and gentlemen, unfortunately, nothing crazy here! It seems this is just the first one graded. CGC doesn’t have it in the system yet, and they might have been a bit lazy or simply forgot to search for the correct name and set. Their quality check seems to be lacking as well.

7 Likes

Common CGC W

1 Like

this is fantastic, and I wish I owned it lol

1 Like

The Blaziken finished first, but my 31 card bulk order feels like it’s moving fast as
​​​

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​
Goin right next to my Sceptiles - will find a swampert eventually

22 Likes

@candle been laser focused for years. Always in the shadows working towards the singular goal

Rookie starters stonking

3 Likes