Unknown Base Set Error, how does this occur during the printing process?

Hello everyone,

I’m aware of this same error being repeated across the D&P Base Set Holos and the Manaphy 4/12 and Lucario 3/11 Promos. Until now I had not seen it on any other sets.

The error appears to be a combination of Holo shift and additional white ink on the white opaque layer. However, the areas of Holo seen on the card are where the white ink should block the Holo from showing, and the areas that are Holo are where the white ink should make it non-holo. Examples are shown below.



Now recently, I was shown a base set Hitmonchan with additional white ink, which looked unlike other white ink errors I have seen. I realised that the same error was happening here, showing the outline of a Ninetales in the holo. Not only this, but I realised that I also had a copy of this error in my collection without realizing it, meaning this is repeated. Pictures below.



I’ve included two more photos below of other similar errors. Any insight would be appreciated!


Thanks :slight_smile:

2 Likes

Would this not be a foil layer misaligned error?

1 Like

I think I saw @qwachansey with a couple of those chansey’s, in the error thread

1 Like

@pfm, perhaps you have an idea?

Wow no need to randomly tag people give, him some explanation on why your tagging him specifically so they aren’t confused on why they are getting tagged when they join lol. Also he can’t answer every question under the sun, sure he can answer questions but there’s others who could probably answer it pfm isn’t the only knowledgeable person in this forum lol.

I believe what your looking at is misaligned layers when the sheet was printing like @lyleberr mentioned you can find a lot of information on it scattered around in this thread Show Off Your Error Cards Megathread! - #783 by lazershark2012 there might be a thread dedicated to just this as well if you want to search for it

3 Likes
8 Likes

So, as mentioned in the video linked above, the way holofoil works is that the nonholo parts of the cards are blocked out by an opaque white blocking layer.

So underneath the body of hitmonchan will be a solid white, the background normally would not receive that so the holo shows through the color ink. In this card, the blocking of hitmonchan seems fine.

The image below suggests that white ink is appearing where it normally would not, which is why this part of the card is nonholo

The odd characteristic is that there seems to be the shape of the Ninetales blocked out, as pointed out:

The error below happened because they used the wrong blocking (ie Kyogre mask used on Groudon and vice vera). It’s a related error but not the same thing. The difference being the Hitmonchan has both Hitmonchan and Ninetales masks simultaneously.

The confusing part is that this is actually the inverted Ninetales layer, ie. the background has the white ink instead of the Ninetales.

The way that the printing machine works is that water and ink (pink roller) are applied to a printing plate. The surface of the plate is designed such that the parts that receive no ink attract water and the parts that should have ink attract oil (oil and water don’t mix), The ink on the printing plate is then put onto a rubber blanket and then rolled onto the paper.

An issue called ghosting can happen when you have areas of high ink concentration right next to areas of low ink concentration. The inconsistent application can cause certain parts of the sheet to be relatively starved of ink example: Explain this to me - #14 by pfm

Ghosting is one way you can have one part of the sheet affect another.

Some kind of mechanical ghosting may be the explanation here… but the weird thing is that the Ninetales layer is inverted.

In contrast to this Chansey, which may be an example of “blanket memory” (a type of ghosting). This is when some of the ink is not released from the blanket and ends up being applied on a subsequent sheet.

I don’t know if I fully have the ability to explain it. But some phenomenon is likely holding the ink on the blanket in the shape of the Ninetales, and redepositing on a subsequent sheet. This explains why both the Hitmonchan ink shape is proper and why you have traces of the Ninetales.

Consider the sheet below.


(note: the sheets go though the rollers left-to-right, not top-to-bottom)

Hope that’s useful

20 Likes

Wow, thank you for such a detailed explanation, I have been stumped by this for a while. You’re the best!