What should a BGS 10 (9.5 corners) English 1st Ed Shining Charizard sell for?
Thanks all…
Anybody have an educated opinion?
You would know as well as anyone, right?
3 Likes
With most things yes but this is a OOAK of a very valuable card so only my opinion isn’t good enough for me.
1 Like
Gary are you just bragging and trolling now 
1 Like
Bragging about what?
About how much your card is worth
3-5 times the PSA 10 value for charizards.
No way. $6,000 - $10,000? Lol
it’s what Gary said, an educated opinion. The BGS 10 1st base sold for 55k when the PSA 10 was $20k (2.75x). The BGS 10 1st Ed dark Charizard sold for $2500 when its PSA 10 was $500. I sold my BGS 10 ex Dragon Charizard for $1200 when its PSA 10 was $350 (3.5x). Gary would be the best person to estimate but everyone has their own and mine is 3-5x PSA 10 value.
3 Likes
I think i saw a pristine 1st shining zard on insta this week with a top offer of 8k. Hope this helps
I don’t own the card though?
Another aspect to consider when comparing to the 1st ed Base BGS 10 copy, the shining is a much easier card to grade
1st ed base: 120 PSA 10, 604 PSA9
16.5% success rate
1st ed shining: 178 PSA 10, 157 PSA 953.1% success rate
There’s probably a few other BGS 10 candidates out there, I would be more conservative about how to value this card, personally.
6 Likes
I’d ballpark it around $5,000-6,000. It’s not an easy grade in a BGS 10 and I doubt anyone is investing in hoarding dozens PSA 10s to try and crossgrade (especially for only a 2-3x multiplier on a single card if anything).
1 Like
Maybe I’m wrong. I guess I’ve seen crazier. I would never pay that much for a BGS card just buy a PSA 10.
4 Likes
I would have estimated $4k. My estimate may be low because PSA 10 is already the top of the mountain for me and I don’t really see excessive value in BGS 10 cards outside 1st edition base Charizard.
7 Likes
Yeah, it’s hard to compare between BGS 10 and PSA 10 on English cards because there’s so few BGS Pristines. All would earn a big premium over PSA 10s though, just hard to show examples of.
1 Like
I don’t want to say exactly where I stand in this however $6,000-10,000 sounds absolutely reasonable to me. If I had the cash on hand I would totally buy it at that price. That’s just me though and I personally collect BGS 10s so that puts a different spin on things…
Mjisaacs
1 Like
Maybe $6k if it had to go to auction. I don’t feel like there’s enough interest for it to hit 5 figures.
1 Like
I’d like to say it would reach $5k 
1 Like