Black/Red dot error + Holo Bleed Charizard/Blastoise?

[boozki]

@mjisaacs

@boozki

Does the black dot one not qualify as a real error? I figured it would be the same as the Blastoise’s red dot since its something thats occur on more than a handful of cards? Or does the red dot not count as one either? Serious question please no flame

I consider the red Dot Blastoise to be a legit error personally. However I’ve been told I consider everything and the kitchen sink to be an error so my vote might not be the best to go off of. I haven’t done enough research on Charizard yet to consider it since a Card has to have at least 5 different cards to be considered an error in my book. Most people do not consider the red Dot error as a real error though to my understanding.
Mjisaacs

Ah okay. Yeah my vote would be legit error personally as well but i could see why people wouldnt consider it one. Ive seen it a few times so atleast i know its not just mold lol. Thank you for your answer

[kiwiblue]

@boozki

@kiwiblue

For sale? ?

Unfortunately since i only have the one i think i want to hold onto it haha

All good

[KingPokemon]

I know where you can get more. Gotta find my sharpie lol.

[missingno]

Y’all are wildin’

[quuador]

Personally I see it as an error as well, but as most of you know, I collect every little variation for my Pikachus. In general though, the black dot on the Base Set Charizard as well as the red dot on the Base Set Blastoise (and the Pink Heart on the Base Set Clefairy and 1st edition spot on the Jungle Pinsir I might add), isn’t a one-time occurrence. For all four of these I’ve seen at least five unique cards containing it. In my book that’s enough to classify it as an error instead of a one-time thing.
They definitely aren’t as excited as a No HP Persian, No Damage Ninetales, Wartortle Evolution Box, Sideways stamp Diglett, etc. etc., but I personally still see them as collectible errors.

Again, I can definitely understand why most people couldn’t care less. The same applies to Thin/Thick, Black/Grey, 2D/3D 1st edition stamps. Some people just see all those as 1st edition stamps and be done with it, others (like myself) see all these as different variations.

Personally I think these holo bleeds are pretty cool in general. Although there are loads of holo bleeds for XY Evolutions and the Sun & Moon sets (for the S&M sets there are almost more with holo bleed than without in my experience… ), I haven’t seen that many holo bleeds for the Base Set personally. Then again, I don’t have that many Base Set holos to begin with. The only Base Set holo with holo bleed I own is this Chansey.

I don’t collect Charizards nor Blastoises, but if I would I definitely would have loved to own these cards.

Just my 2c, though.

Greetz,
Quuador

[mjisaacs]

@quuador

Personally I see it as an error as well, but as most of you know, I collect every little variation for my Pikachus. In general though, the black dot on the Base Set Charizard as well as the red dot on the Base Set Blastoise (and the Pink Heart on the Base Set Clefairy and 1st edition spot on the Jungle Pinsir I might add), isn’t a one-time occurrence. For all four of these I’ve seen at least five unique cards containing it. In my book that’s enough to classify it as an error instead of a one-time thing.
They definitely aren’t as excited as a No HP Persian, No Damage Ninetales, Wartortle Evolution Box, Sideways stamp Diglett, etc. etc., but I personally still see them as collectible errors.

Again, I can definitely understand why most people couldn’t care less. The same applies to Thin/Thick, Black/Grey, 2D/3D 1st edition stamps. Some people just see all those as 1st edition stamps and be done with it, others (like myself) see all these as different variations.

Personally I think these holo bleeds are pretty cool in general. Although there are loads of holo bleeds for XY Evolutions and the Sun & Moon sets (for the S&M sets there are almost more with holo bleed than without in my experience… ), I haven’t seen that many holo bleeds for the Base Set personally. Then again, I don’t have that many Base Set holos to begin with. The only Base Set holo with holo bleed I own is this Chansey.

I don’t collect Charizards nor Blastoises, but if I would I definitely would have loved to own these cards.

Just my 2c, though.

Greetz,
Quuador

I completely agree with your two cents. It just means another error to add to my never ending list of errors!
Thanks for confirming there is at least 5 of the Charizard Error, know I can always count on you @quuador
Mjisaacs

[jameskray]

wait is this error like the blastoise red dot if so i bloody now need it in a psa 9 lol

[mrbug]

@mjisaacs

@quuador

Personally I see it as an error as well, but as most of you know, I collect every little variation for my Pikachus. In general though, the black dot on the Base Set Charizard as well as the red dot on the Base Set Blastoise (and the Pink Heart on the Base Set Clefairy and 1st edition spot on the Jungle Pinsir I might add), isn’t a one-time occurrence. For all four of these I’ve seen at least five unique cards containing it. In my book that’s enough to classify it as an error instead of a one-time thing.
They definitely aren’t as excited as a No HP Persian, No Damage Ninetales, Wartortle Evolution Box, Sideways stamp Diglett, etc. etc., but I personally still see them as collectible errors.

Again, I can definitely understand why most people couldn’t care less. The same applies to Thin/Thick, Black/Grey, 2D/3D 1st edition stamps. Some people just see all those as 1st edition stamps and be done with it, others (like myself) see all these as different variations.

Personally I think these holo bleeds are pretty cool in general. Although there are loads of holo bleeds for XY Evolutions and the Sun & Moon sets (for the S&M sets there are almost more with holo bleed than without in my experience… ), I haven’t seen that many holo bleeds for the Base Set personally. Then again, I don’t have that many Base Set holos to begin with. The only Base Set holo with holo bleed I own is this Chansey.

I don’t collect Charizards nor Blastoises, but if I would I definitely would have loved to own these cards.

Just my 2c, though.

Greetz,
Quuador

I completely agree with your two cents. It just means another error to add to my never ending list of errors!
Thanks for confirming there is at least 5 of the Charizard Error, know I can always count on you @quuador
Mjisaacs

I wouldn’t consider the heart clef airy an error at all, just some dude with a stamp trying to trick people.

I’m also of the mindset if you need to turn lights off and shine a light on it to see a bleed, it’s not really a bleed. cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/451952294821625864/454182197616705536/20180606_235359_1.gif normal lighting bleed

[ptccards]

I agree with the blastoise as i personally have one with bunch of small red ink dots.

[joetehman]

Had a 1st edition or shadowless blastoise with that red dot in the same place as well.

[kiwiblue]

@joetehman

Had a 1st edition or shadowless blastoise with that red dot in the same place as well.

What happened to it?

[mrbug]

@kiwiblue

@joetehman

Had a 1st edition or shadowless blastoise with that red dot in the same place as well.

What happened to it?

Euthanized - it was a matter of quality of life

[ajs1992]

Just bought a black dot charizard from a card shop few days ago. Thought it was a sharpy mark until I did some reseach online and found a few with the same exact dot on the nintendo.

imgur.com/a/XqiyyAE

[mikejofthecoast]

Be right back, let me go check all my base set charizardsssss

[modernrocket]

@mikejofthecoast

Be right back, let me go check all my base set charizardsssss

2nd to the last one! Found one!

[fourthstartcg]

Posts in threads with a last post of over two months ago are against the rules.