I don’t see that anywhere under sold. By the way, to everyone, just because sales history says “x item sold, best offer accepted” does NOT mean it actually sold. There are many glitches–it is beyond frustrating. I personally contacted the lucky guy who had the 35k 1st ed PSA 10 Chansey asking what price he took for it. Because I mean, c’mon, its the rarest card in the set at a 10. He said he just took the listing down opting to keep it after all. Said it sold, best offer accepted. So you can’t always go off of that, which stinks.
Yeah I kind of agree with that, but I feel that BGS 9s are still quite consistent. I regraded BGS 9 into PSA 9 numerous times (might be lucky). However anything under that feels like a waste of money and would most likely grade one grade less with PSA.
^This. I have a few BGS 9’s that are on par with PSA 9’s but as stated before, anything below a BGS 9 is super inconsistent. I believe Scott made a video regarding this awhile ago.
I do think the whole BGS 9.5 deal is super gimmicky. You see it with some of Pokerev’s streams - he’ll tell people to grade w/ BGS because it has a chance at a 9.5 compared to getting a PSA 9. I believe I’ve seen this saying on here before but, “the best way to sell a PSA 9 is in a BGS 9.5 case.” I just don’t see why someone would pay a premium for a 9.5 compared to just buying a strong 9 when they look exactly the same (in most cases).
@mewtuw, I’m well aware that in Pokemon, when I’m buying a BGS 9.5 it’s usually a regraded strong 9 or a would-be-9-but-not-PSA-10. Personally I don’t see an issue with that at all, because it’s frustrating getting weak 9s, especially if you want the card in a certain condition for your personal collection. It’s not always easy to find a strong 9 and people already have started adding to the price for a “strong” PSA grade so may as well get the BGS 9.5. Hence the whole point of a middle 9.5
For what it’s worth in relation to the psa 8, I got an offer of $14K for my PSA 7 today. I think psa 8s are well into the $20K and up range at this point. Edit: there are still 4 listed, 3 of them are at or above $30K.