Skyridge or Aquapolis would be great as I love the holos artwork, 1st edition base set would be huge as well, but I would love to open one of those Japanese starter decks boxes from the very beginning, filled with no rarity cards. Imagine pulling a no rarity Charizard, very first ever charizard printed
Tough question I have 3 options any of which I would be happy with.
Japanese Neo 4/Neo destiny as I never got to pull a shining card.
Base Set for the nostalgia.
Skyridge as the only really rare card I ever pulled as a kid was crystal golem and at the time I never even realised so to do that again knowing the rarity would be an awesome experience.
For me, just for nostalgiaās sake, I would say EX Legend Maker or Diamond and Pearl Mysterious Treasures.
When I first got into Pokemon in 2008, these were the most common booster packs to find in local stores (with a mix of DP Base, Secret Wonders, and Power Keepers). Not even caring about the money, I would just love to relive some of those memories by opening one of those again.
Got into PkMn in 1999 in Japanese, with Team Rocket and then Gym 2, so Iād crack a Team Rocket JP. Holo in every pack, and good art. Second to that, tied between Eng Neo Revelations, 1st ed (of course) and aquapolis. Decent art in both, but I never opened a single aquapolis pack. my issue with the old WotC boxes is that your hopes can be so high and the nostalgia so strong, but the disappointment can be as well⦠So, Iād probably go with the Aquapolis, but only after the JP rocket.
Edit:
Since not specified, 1st box would be tied between cracking JP Rocket, and Drafting Acacyn Restored. NICE draft experience in that set!
Iād have to go with EX Dragon Frontiers. Incredible artwork, fantastic selection of ex cards, and the chance to pull some amazing gold stars. Close runners-up would probably be EX Dragon and EX Unseen Forces.
Thinking about the opening experience, you want to choose a set where A) you get reverse holos and B) the reverse holos mean something. So that takes us down to legendary collection, e-series and ex era.
You want as many top tier hits as possible. You only get a couple ex per box and while the holos in ex era are gorgeous, they donāt hold the weight of WOTC holos. That takes us down to legendary collection and e-series.
Iām going to remove legendary collection just due to the reprint nature of it.
You want a shot at pulling a crystal card so that removes Expedition.
Finally we get down to Aquapolis or Skyridge. Aquapolis is actually my favourite set of all time, but Iām much closer to completing it, so in this situation, I have to choose Skyridge.
I would love to open anything from ex era really. Itās so hard to choose which set though. If I didnāt have a full set of reverses already I would go with Emerald as itās my favorite set of all time. But tbh I would love to open a box that would have a chance for a Gold Star pull as I never pulled one from a pack. Delta Species could be amazing to open I feel like.