To reholder or not to reholder?

Grading Question
,
1

With the recent craze of low pop vintage I’m evaluating what to do with these sequential reverse Call of Legends cards.

The Groudon is Pop 1 PSA 10 and Pop 1 CGC Gem Mint 10 and the Kyogre is Pop 5 PSA 10, Pop 3 CGC Gem Mint.

While I think leaning into these being the only pair of blue label CGC Gem Mints that will ever exist adds to their uniqueness, the recent Mew ex Perfect going for ‘only’ 13k more than the PSA 10 a couple weeks prior makes me wonder if preserving that uniqueness is worthwhile in this market.

PXL_20261007_185520693
PXL_20261007_1855206931920×3413 1.8 MB

2

If they are for sale, leave them as they are and allow the buyer to make the choice

3

If you are looking at the value, reholder. Cgc is already losing you value against psa, you need for people to see the number 10 on them to hit higher values.

4

If you want to sell them → Reholder. CGC 10 Gem Mint > CGC 9.5 Gem Mint in buyers’ minds.

If you want to keep them and like the old labels → Don’t Reholder.

6

Probably the ugliest label in the history of slabs. Reholder asap.