The Giant Professional Grading Thread

They keep dropping the price and I keep getting returns back in the same amount of time. I think they’ll keep dropping.

They keep sending me offers between $50-100 off a grading submission. So far I haven’t bitten, mainly because there are other things I would rather spend the money on at the moment. I think we could see further price drops. $10/card might be the right price point to bring a lot of people back in.

Also, the economics of grading have changed a lot since PSA raised their prices, they will have to adjust to that at some point

1 Like

Am I crazy that I’m considering buying CGCs Elite membership and sending ~400 cards into CGC’s Munich office?

1 Like

I think they’ll go lower. TAT are still hovering around 50% of their Estimated TAT, which is screaming to me that they aren’t getting the volume they’ve hoped for from these small specials. There’s been a TCG special almost every month since June and subs are still coming back in a month or so

Is it possible to grade PSA Authentic for the $24.99 tier non-subscriber? Not seeing it

I had to write “Authentic only” in big sharpie on the invoice I sent last time I wanted a sports card as authentic. That was over a year ago so don’t know if the process is any different

1 Like

To all my expert graders! What is your grade guess on this card? Sending to PSA and hoping it hits a 9 or 10.


Can’t see this not hitting a 9 or 10

2 Likes

Tbh, 16,000 of the 17,000 graded by PSA are 9 or 10 so chances are pretty damn good!

1 Like

Let’s play a game.
How is this a 4?


Even with a dent, this should be a 5/6.

I have the card in hand and couldn’t see any dents. Do you see something I am missing?

2 Likes

Could be a typo or mistake

1 Like

The cert only had three '4’s so they added one more just so you would get four '4’s

4 Likes

Here’s one I recently cracked for the binder:

Those are images from the listing. What I found was a crease along the bottom middle on the front and there was a dent next to the retreat cost. I imagine this combo reflects the grade and maybe it’s a similar story with yours. Still looks great in a binder!

3 Likes


image

found a few of these scrolling pwcc

10 Likes

I recently had a Base Machamp that I pregraded a 9 get a 4. With how little time graders spend on each card, sometimes they think they see something that isn’t actually there.

I cracked and regraded it, should be getting the new grade any day now.

Welp, I officially had my worst PSA order. Lack of consistency on grading standards, low overall grades, and slowest turnaround time that I’ve had in over a year.

The past 3-4 months of submissions have steadily been getting worse and worse in my experience. Like I get it, we agree to the bullshit, but I’m getting tired of this. Gonna resubmit a huge part of this order and see what happens…

On the bright side, this was a nice diamond in the rough:

7 Likes

For some reason he looks even more menacing in German

7 Likes

It’s an intimidating language!

4 Likes

If anyone was curious this did hit a 10!

18 Likes

Ayyy congrats!