Has anyone tried Reholder service to replace the case of your old PSA card?
There are a few things I want to know:
Will the serial number change?
Will you get the new case with hologram? (my main motivation)
Can you submit it together with grading submissions?
Considering you can submit it together with grading submissions, it is only $7 per card + return shipping with your graded cards.
Do you think it is worth it?
The grade won’t change, right?? 
2-3. Yes
4b. It’s up to you to decide bud, I can’t make your collection goals for you.
@cullers Separate return shipping is a bummer. PSA charges $18 shipping for even 1 card within US.
It was/is totally worth it to me. I didn’t like having sets of PSA cards, some with the holo and some without. I have some now where the backs do/don’t have serial numbers but I’m not too bothered about that. What’s even worse is having PSA cards that are scratched up (sometimes I cringe at how people must be treating them, or when I see people sliding them across surfaces in videos), so I want all my cases to be as minty and clear as possible. It’s a shame that they really seem to scratch easily, and some of them come like that from PSA.
The cards in my collection I intend to keep for a very long time so that’s another reason it’s worth it to me.
@xuzu Exactly! I don’t plan on reselling any of my cards. I only collects and treat my cards like they are my babies. So, I want them as new and minty as possible. 
To better help your decision, if your card has the older case, I would recommend re-holdering for the newer case. While the older design is not bad, the newer case is more solid in my opinion. I personally will have to re-holder some of my cards I graded years ago.
@smpratte
What do you charge for reholder service?
Honestly depends on the amount of cards. The problem is that people typically want to submit only a couple cards, which PSA charges $18-20 for return shipping. This is why I suggest grading 10 cards for $10.50 each, as the price point is optimal for everyone.
Thank you.
Everyone be careful with what plastic comes in contact with PSA cases. I have a case that has 80% cloudiness on the front when some plastic stuck to it.
Yes! I reholdered my most valuable cards. The new cases are much nicer to hold and frame your prized cards better in a more appealing manner.
That’s cute, $18.
One card international is $55. Fucking lunacy.
I have an additional question regarding reholdering. What experiences do people have? Was there ever a card damaged by PSA? I’m a bit scared to submit my expensive cards for reholdering 
If you send out PSA graded cards re-holdering PSA will have verified the cards upon receipt and confirm the cards and grades. If during the re-holdering process the card is damaged they would have no way out. They would be caught red handed. They couldn’t as in the case of sending a gem mint card raw card to them for grading just grade it a 5 from a bent corner and send it back claiming it came in that way. There is no proof upon sending raw cards that get damaged, but they would have no way to refute damage on a review. Only two options are that it was in the case damaged to begin with which they would call an “oversight” on the initial grading and they would have PSA grade guarantee kick in, or they would have to claim the damage as their own, re-grade it post damage and also have some kind of PSA grade guarantee kick in.
I am leery of sending in valuable raw cards, but regrades I would have absolutely 0% concern over.
I have 5 or 6 PSA cards I bought on eBay back a while ago, nothing high dollar. The moron stacked them and literally wrapped them in packing tape DIRECTLY ON THE SLABS. Top and bottom ones are totally wrecked. Sides of all the others are sticky. These have been set aside for re-holder but such low value cards I haven’t been able to justify their own re-holder submission yet. One I actually wanted to try getting the tape residue off and used some IPA I had. 0/10 would not recommend. Completely clouded the whole front of the case lol.
I am sure @garyis2000 would like this story.
@gottaketchumall if its adhesive residue on the case try use some Eucalyptus Oil! That should get it off.
To answer your question from experience, I don’t worry of damage. If anything the card already being graded will protect it better in transit, which is where most cards are most likely damaged.
Re-holder service is probably the least used service at PSA. Probably only a handful of collectors here actually have used the service. I would personally worry more about a raw card in transit than one already graded.
Good point, thanks Scott 
I really want to reholder some cards
Same here! My 1997 pika set and illustrator need a re-holding, but will probably wait until they have a show close that I can go in person.
I reholdered a 1998 no. 1 trainer with no problem and fast turnaround. Real cheap, very easy experience.