(Part 1) Gen 3/ex Sets Holo Rare Grail Poll

Does that black star promo Suicune have any Raikou or Entei friends?

No, unfortunately not. :frowning:

They are overshadowed (and possibly even ousted) for a reason. Their artworks are less appealing and lacking something.

Even the Mew holo rare card listed here, I don’t find it appealing enough to cast a vote for it, despite me being a Mew fan.

I have to skip this poll, I’m afraid…

Yea, so many amazing holos excluded. Not sure the point of a poll like this when tons of cards people mightve voted for arent even included. I feel like this should be done in sections or by sets and then including the top winners from each set.

4 Likes

I will miss you

6 Likes

If my boy isn’t in part 2 I’ll riot…

1 Like

The fact that Lunatone is not on here is such a shame :pensive:
Screenshot_20240201_193811_Google

4 Likes

Damn @wisewailmer you managed to upset every species collector in one single post

3 Likes

Lol I know. I’m not sure people realize I’m probably one of the biggest fans of all these cards. Even the lamest of lame camerupt from RS.

But it’s supposed to be a poll for finding the best most iconic card of ex era. I’m not going to put in stuff like Butterfree, lunatone, crawdaunt etc etc. The Eevees in SS have the closest honorable mention imo but I’d be lying to myself if I thought they were the most iconic holos of the era (if Umbreon had an English Holo I’d throw that in)

It sounds like most people wanna do a tier list of everything which is fine, but I think we may have done that already. If not we can.

I thought that people would be able to realize that even if it’s your favorite card, it does not make it the grail icon of the era

3 Likes

Youre making the assumption some cards wont got voted for but you dont know that for sure

Yes I am

I really like this shift in E4 where we have tons of card polls, in addition to collection threads this has been a great showcase of such beautiful cards and nice conversations around them!

5 Likes

Honestly, I wouldn’t know if any of them were iconic or not since I didn’t collect them during the period. Just voted for whatever I liked.

2 Likes

We’re really eroding at the concept of ā€œgrailā€ aren’t we

2 Likes

its part of the r/pokeinvestors psyop to water down the definition enough to include anything and everything

3 Likes

Yeah lol. I guess each category is too different. I was very curious to see what the best of each type would be but I think most people just want a tier list of everything. That’s a good topic too but not exactly something I’m super interested in since it’ll be different for everyone.

I figured we could reach some sort of concrete-ish definition of grail as imo there’s only a few real contenders. But if we need to have every beautifly represented idk it’s probably more work than it’s worth

Don’t let me stop you from having fun. The concept of ā€œgrailā€ has been meaningless for years at this point :slight_smile: . Or completely redefined from it’s origin at least Holy Grail - Wikipedia

1 Like

Interesting results:
Dragon Charizard at #1
Emerald Rayquaza #2

Both come from sets that do not have gold stars. They knew they had to spice up the sets somehow I guess

Art is gonna be subjective but imo with the exception of sets with great regular card themeing (TRR, Delta Species/Holon Phantoms, Unseen Forces) the post-ereader holos kinda just…exist. Their inclusion feels more like a formality rather than something that contributes to set identity.

1 Like