E4's Favorite Wailmer & Wailord (Closed - Results)

How this works:

  • the “Design” poll is just to get a rough count of participants
  • cards are listed in chronological order based on first release
  • each card will have a picture followed by the option to vote for it.
  • vote for any card that you like.
  • on Sunday at 12PM Pacific Time, the polls will automatically close. I will edit this post and title to count down from least to most voted, and we will see which cards are E4’s Favorite.

Note: Most of these images are pulled from quick google searches, eBay, or Bulbapedia if they had a large enough file. If you'd like me to replace an image, you're welcome to post it in the comments.


Results

at least 88 Participants

Design

6.79 / 10 - Wailmer (87 Votes)
7.47 / 10 - Wailord (88 Votes)


Cards

The Worst Wails

Less than 1/10 Liked

37/38th - 2 Votes

26 tt gx sr
28 tt gx hr

36th - 3 Votes

31 V

35th - 4 Votes

18 EX RR

34th - 7 Votes

16 bw5

33rd - 8 Votes

30 sm11a


Meh Wails

Between 1/10 and 1/5 Liked

32nd - 9 Votes

05 tmvta

28th-31st - 10 Votes

10 dp4
12 pt3
17 bw5
34 s11

27th - 11 Votes

22 sm7

26th - 13 Votes

24 sm7 aa gym

24/25th - 14 Votes

23 sm7
36 s11a

23rd - 15 Votes

20 sm2L

21st/22nd - 16 Votes

03 RS
32 s4

20th - 17 Votes

33 s4


Decent Wails

Between 1/5 and 1/3 Liked

19th - 19 Votes

09 worlds 06

16-18th - 20 Votes

14 L3
15 L3
19 EX SR

15th - 21 Votes

37 s11a

14th - 29 Votes

35 s11


Good Wails (Honorable Mentions)

Between 1/3 and 1/2 Liked

13th - 35 Votes

13 pt3

12th - 39 Votes

29 sm11a

11th - 43 Votes

38 phione ar


Great Wails

More than 1/2 Liked

10th - 46 Votes

07 mirage

9th - 47 Votes

01 rosss

8th - 48 Votes

25 tt gx rr

7th - 50 Votes

02 RS

6th - 52 Votes

06 mirage

5th - 53 Votes

11 dp4

4th - 54 Votes

04 ex


The Best Wails

More than 2/3 Liked

Tie :2nd_place_medal: / :3rd_place_medal: - 60 Votes

2nd

1st :1st_place_medal: - 61 Votes

08 ana pika


Polls

Design

Voting Scale:

[ 1 The Worst ] ↔ [ 10 The Best ]

0320Wailmer

How would you rate Wailmer as a Pokemon
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters

0321Wailord

How would you rate Wailord as a Pokemon
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
0 voters

Cards

VS / e Series

  • 2002 - Ross’s Wailmer
0 voters

ADV-PCG / EX

  • 2003 - Wailmer - Expansion Pack / EX Ruby & Sapphire
0 voters
  • 2003 - Wailord - Expansion Pack / EX Ruby & Sapphire
0 voters
  • 2003 - Wailord ex
0 voters
  • 2003 - Wailmer - TMvTA / Sandstorm
0 voters
  • 2005 - Wailmer - Mirage Forest / Legend Maker
0 voters
  • 2005 - Wailord - Mirage Forest / Legend Maker
0 voters
  • 2006 - Wailmer Cameo Pikachu - PCG-P ANA Pikachu Summer Trip Campaign / POP 5, DP Value Box (Cosmos Holo)
0 voters
  • 2006 - Wailmer Cameo - Worlds '06 Tropical Tidal Wave
0 voters

DP / Pt

  • 2007 - Wailmer - DP4 / Great Encounters
0 voters
  • 2007 - Wailord - DP4 / Great Encounters
0 voters
  • 2009 - Wailmer - Pt3 / Supreme Victors
0 voters
  • 2009 - Wailord - Pt3 / Supreme Victors
0 voters

L / HGSS

  • 2010 - Wailmer - L3 / Triumphant
0 voters
  • 2010 - Wailord - L3 / Triumphant
0 voters

BW

  • 2012 - Wailmer - BW5 / Dragons Exalted
0 voters
  • 2012 - Wailord - BW5 / Dragons Exalted
0 voters

XY

  • 2014 - Wailord EX
0 voters
  • 2014 - Wailord EX SR (Full Art)
0 voters

SM

  • 2017 - Wailmer - sm2L / Guardians Rising
0 voters
  • 2017 - Wailord - sm2L / Guardians Rising
0 voters
  • 2018 - Wailmer - sm7 / Celestial Storm
0 voters
  • 2018 - Wailord - sm7 / Celestial Storm
0 voters
  • 2018 - Wailmer - SM-P Gym (sm7 AA)
0 voters
  • 2018 - Wailord TT GX
0 voters
  • 2018 - Wailord TT GX SR (Full Art)
0 voters
  • 2018 - Wailord TT GX SA (Special Art)
0 voters
  • 2018 - Wailord TT GX HR (Rainbow)
0 voters
  • 2019 - Wailmer - sm11a / Cosmic Eclipse
0 voters
  • 2019 - Wailord - sm11a / Cosmic Eclipse
0 voters

SwSh

  • 2020 - Wailord V
0 voters
  • 2020 - Wailmer - s4 / Vivid Voltage
0 voters
  • 2020 - Wailord - s4 / Vivid Voltage
0 voters
  • 2022 - Wailmer - s11 / Silver Tempest
0 voters
  • 2022 - Wailord - s11 / Silver Tempest
0 voters
  • 2022 - Wailmer - s11a / Crown Zenith
0 voters
  • 2022 - Wailord - s11a / Crown Zenith
0 voters

SV

  • 2024 - Cameo - Phione AR/IR
0 voters

https://www.elitefourum.com/t/e4s-favorite-polls-archive/46473

5 Likes

Long overdue. Thought for sure this would be one of the first polls

24 Likes

Wailord has been very consistent, lots of votes and none of them felt gratuitous.

3 Likes

this card is so insane.

as for dedicated cards, my personal favorites


10 Likes

Wailmer peaked in highschool

3 Likes

Not even the detestable GX borders could destroy this card.

8 Likes

Yea, I love whales, great pokemon and great art!

5 Likes

Carvanha and Sharpedo are far superior but some nice arts nonetheless

I don’t think I voted for a single wailmer card….

3 Likes

I just vote for the silliest ones.

3 Likes

That boat Arita Wailmer is peak.

2 Likes

Surprisingly big amount of great cards even though the quality severely dropped with the shift into modern, but still there’s only one possible winner. Komiya’s way of drawing any round pokemon is my number one joy in life so i don’t want to live in a world where cosmic eclipse wailmer isn’t the king of this poll.

3 Likes

Arita’s Wailmer of R/S ooff love that one

1 Like

@inertgeometry Big thanks to you for always putting in so much effort into making these community polls. I am very happy you could find the time to make one for Wailmer and Wailord!

Now I am obviously biased but I think with the exception of the Ken Sugimori and the 5ban GX Fullart wailord does not have any bad cards (and the Ken Sugimori art is not bad, it’s the composition of the card with the wailord just floating there that irks me).
Whales tend to have smooth, slippery skin and in my eyes that’s what makes wailord pull off even cgi artwork.
There is not really an artwork that I like the best but there are some that do notably stand out like the 2022 Wailord from S11a / Crown Zenith by KIYOTAKA OSHIYAMA, that through the inclusion of dozens of tiny Wishiwashis underlines Wailord’s huge size and the Wailord and Wailmer cameos in the 2024 Phione AR that show its herding behaviour - which are both mentioned in Wailord’s pokemon dex entries. E.g.:

Wailord pursue their prey in pods. With their large mouths, they can swallow entire schools of Wishiwashi whole. (Pokémon Sun)

and

When a small Wailmer is attacked by Sharpedo or Dhelmise, its whole pod works together to protect it. (Pokémon Ultra Moon)

In the future I would love to see a Wailord card featuring an artwork from the perspective of a whale watching boat. I think that could be a fun idea for an AR or CHR.

Its immense size is the reason for its popularity. Wailord watching is a favorite sightseeing activity in various parts of the world. (Pokémon Shield)

6 Likes

Oh and while I do love Kimura’s Pikachu, please don’t let a rat become the most popular Wailmer/Wailord card.
431117292521127937

6 Likes

I didn’t even notice the wishiwashi on crown zenith one until you mentioned them, a fun detail even though a lot of them probably aren’t going to make it :sushi:

4 Likes

I understand why you and @WailordEnthusiast love this pokemon. So many card arts alone with great designs.

7 Likes

I agree, the standard sugimori wailord is a big disappointment. It’s so torpedo like and doesn’t look like an animal at all. Ueda did a far better job

3 Likes

Love how Wailmer/Wailord have so many more votable artworks than legendaries and big hype Pokemon like Gengar. At least in my opinion…

It seems to be one of those where the normal non-chase cards are mostly great.

The Cosmic Eclipse Komiya Wailmer is my absolute fave. It just looks like a bunch of whacky Wailmer rolling about on a psychedelic green sea and having a whale of a time (sorry…)

Never seen that Ooyama Wailord from Guardians Rising before though…I think I want one now. This is one reason I love these polls.

3 Likes

I haven’t seen a good chunk of these Wailmer/Wailord cards, so this was a fun poll to go through! I didn’t realize the Tag Team GX version seemed to draw inspiration from an older card Arita illustrated—pretty neat to see!

One card that looks off to me is Himeno’s art in Celestial Storm:

This Wailmer is freakishly gigantic (or I’m just not understanding something with the perspective)

3 Likes