hey guys i have a beckett 9 dark riachu holo error card. i want to have this card graded by PSA instead. do i need to break open the beckett slap and send my card in the traditional card saver way? or could i just send psa the beckett graded card? this is a first for me lol! thanks!
A BGS 9 is extremely unlikely to ever cross to a PSA 10, but it has indeed been done. It may or may not cross to a PSA 9 depending on the subgrades and the actual condition of the card. Many BGS 9.5’s don’t even cross to PSA 10’s though either.
BGS 10 > PSA 10 > BGS 9.5 > PSA 9 > BGS 9 is typically the hierarchy. Every card should easily cross to the grade to it’s right since it is technically a downgrade* but crossing to the left requires that card to be very “solid” at it’s grade. Crossing BGS 9 to PSA 10 would be shifting three places left which would be quite atypical, but it has been done on occasion especially when the centering is an 8 or 8.5 and the other subs are very high.
*downgrade not only in my opinion but more importantly also in the eyes of the market as this is also the value hierarchy found in frequently traded well established cards.