Which would you choose - Masaki Gengar vs Grand Party vs Fan Club Porygon

If you could choose one only, which card will you buy for your collection?

The psa 9 gengar, psa 10 grand party and psa 9 porygon have similar prices.

image

  • PSA 9 Masaki Gengar
  • PSA 10 Grand Party
  • PSA 9 Fan Club Porygon
0 voters
4 Likes

Masaki Gengar is the best of the three.

6 Likes

gengar

2 Likes

Polygon

4 Likes

image

6 Likes

Grand Party. I actually am considering buying a PSA 10 soon.

3 Likes

Really like both the Grand Party and Masaki Gengar. Can’t go wrong either way

2 Likes

party time

2 Likes

Grand Party Gang!

I do love the backstory behind both the Grand Party and Masaki cards.

3 Likes

Grand Party :tada:

3 Likes

Porygon

3 Likes

Porygon - I’m one of the 4 people on earth that prefer the WEB version of the Gengar. It even retains the holo!

3 Likes

Gengar has an impressive following of dedicated species collectors I’ve discovered, I’d have to go with that one.

Skyridge Gengar Holo, FRLG Gengar ex, Phantom Forces Gengar FA… all currently at or above what they were during the boom period. Even Gengar from 1st Ed Fossil has been pretty resilient. Real interest, real fans; not as much a large proportion of speculative buyers.

2 Likes

Porygon.

3 Likes

Grand party all the way

3 Likes

:tada:

3 Likes

All are great cards and I’m sure eventually a buyer would want to add all 3 to their collection some day. I personally have the Porygon as a 9 and the Gengar and Grand Party in lower grades, but if I had to do it again I would go for the Gengar then Grand Party then the Porygon.

3 Likes

that’s tough. they’re all pretty bad. i guess i like the gengar the most out of these options

4 Likes

Grand partay for may

4 Likes

Tough choice… I would want all 3.

If i have to pick, I will probably buy gengar first. Followed by porygon then grand party.

3 Likes