Yeah it’s pretty much impossible to have nostalgia for limited promos and trophies. Because that would mean as a kid you were actively hunting them down in the pre internet times. Or you were competing and winning them.
Obviously you can have big respect for their history and impact but it’s not the same as nostalgia
Really late here but I read all the debate further up about Crystal Charizard and “bad” Charizards, and I have to chip in and say that Charizard ex from FRLG is far worse than most mentioned! It has borked anatomy, a broken-looking neck, and just looks totally wrong the more you look at it.
I had a NM copy in my collection until recently when I realised I was only keeping it for what it is rather than because it was a good art. Sold it for close to £400 and don’t miss it at all.
I think the new grey is better than SOME yellows. But I’d have preferred a dull-yellow or black to make the cards pop. Banana Boat yellow always bugged me though.
edit: Also, I actually really like many of the designs from the S/V gen. As time goes on, simple designs have to give-way to more complex ones. They can’t make another generic Korba, so they make a Seviper. Then they make a Serperior… Sandaconda… ?
Otherwise, you get Digglet… Wigglet… Jigglet… Twigglet… after just 4 generations.
To be fair, the mighty Ooyama carries this art imo. I like this card but I still don’t like this Pokemon (or a lot of Gen 5 > designs).
There are other instances of cards in newer sets where I don’t really like the Pokemon involved but the likes of Komiya and Kanda make a good art in general out of it.