damn, I was really close in buying all 3 goldstar PSA10 dogs from cardhouse.eu on ebay, didn’t know that they made some shady deals. Could you please elaborate on what they did?
There is a thread here on efour about it - but basically it looks like someone did something shady at the factory and took hundreds (Thousands?) of Unseen Forces gold stars from a factory somewhere. More than would have been packaged into boxes. He has hundreds of them he can grade at like PSA 8-10 whenever he wants - so the $200 price currently is probably pretty artificial atm, even if its low.
Which honestly sucks - especially as Suicune has one of the best Gold Star artworks of them all. I still love the art on the card however
The other members already explained but as a bonus tip, do check the blacklist here so you can be aware of who did what and shady buyers/sellers to keep an eye out for.
The POP 5 series gold stars, Umbreon and Espeon, will probably be a solid investment long term. This is because they are non-holos, which means no weighing , and they were not released in a standard set, so the print should be smaller. Also, since the packs were only 2 cards, the gradablity of them is often weaker (or harder) than those from 10 card packs. GS charizard is also a good long term investment but it is not underrated or overlooked.
Also the OG 3, Torchic Mudkip and Treecko, I believe are highly underrated. Team Rocket Returns is such an extremely popular so the pack price is very high, and they were the first gold stars.
TL:DR Umbreon, Espeon, Torchic, Mudkip, and Treecko
The only ones that do it for me are the OG eeveelutions, maybe since no one has mentioned them that says something?
To me the trio were a safe buy. I love all three species, there are around 60/70 in the population as a 10 as well as still “affordable” at around $400-450 each.