Top ten most valuable pokemon

Market
1

Without looking up prices or doing research I thought it would be really fun and informative for people to list what ten pokemon they think others would pay the most for, all rarity, set and beauty of the card art being equal, excluding charizard which hands down is the number one by the numbers. And then make a second list of your top ten personal favorites that if money didn’t matter to you, you would want on that card.

Other People’s List:

  1. Lugia
  2. Blastoise
  3. Pikachu
  4. Rayquaza
  5. Venusaur
  6. Mew
  7. Mewtwo
  8. Espeon
  9. Umbreon
  10. Ho-Oh

My List

  1. Gyarados
  2. Alakazam
  3. Mewtwo
  4. Hypno
  5. Gengar
  6. Dragonite
  7. Arcanine
  8. Blastoise
  9. Mew
  10. Magikarp
8 Likes
2

Top 10 Pay the Most For Pokemon (excluding Charizard):

  1. Pikachu
  2. Mewtwo
  3. Mew
  4. Magikarp
  5. Gyarados
  6. Rayquaza
  7. Blastoise
  8. Venusaur
  9. Pichu
  10. Gengar

Top Ten Favorites:

  1. Gyarados
  2. Volcarona
  3. Mewtwo
  4. Magikarp
  5. Scyther
  6. Scizor
  7. Alakazam
  8. Nidoking
  9. Jigglypuff
  10. Totodile
2 Likes
3

Others list minus Zard:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Mewtwo
  3. Mew
  4. Blastoise
  5. Lugia
  6. Umbreon
  7. Rayquaza
  8. Espeon
  9. Venusaur
  10. Ho-Oh

My favorites list excluding Charizard since he’s automatic #1 for me.

  1. Pikachu
  2. Mewtwo
  3. Mew
  4. Umbreon
  5. Dragonite
  6. Ho-Oh
  7. Raichu
  8. Celebi
  9. Rayquaza
    10.Blastoise
2 Likes
4

I like this idea.

Other People’s List:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Mew
  3. Mewtwo
  4. Lugia
  5. Blastoise
  6. Rayquaza
  7. Espeon
  8. Umbreon
  9. Snorlax
  10. Lucario

My List.

  1. Cubone
  2. Golduck
  3. Bulbasaur
  4. Squirtle
  5. Charmander
  6. Empoleon
  7. Snorlax
  8. Psyduck
  9. Flareon
  10. Growlithe
1 Like
5

This took longer than I thought it would…

Other people:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Lugia
  3. Mew
  4. Rayquaza
  5. Blastoise
  6. Mewtwo
  7. Eevee
  8. Umbreon
  9. Venusaur
  10. Gengar

Me:

  1. Lugia
  2. Pikachu
  3. Articuno
  4. Umbreon
  5. Mewtwo
  6. Mew
  7. Charmander
  8. Suicune
  9. Rayquaza
  10. Snorlax
1 Like
6

Other People’s List:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Rayquaza
  3. Lugia
  4. Mew
  5. Blastoise
  6. Mewtwo
  7. Venusaur
  8. Gengar
  9. Dragonite
  10. Umbreon

My List:

  1. Blastoise
  2. Blastoise
  3. Blastoise
  4. Blastoise
  5. Blastoise
  6. Blastoise
  7. Blastoise
  8. Blastoise
  9. Blastoise
  10. Blastoise
5 Likes
7

Other People’s List:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Mew
  3. Lugia
  4. Mewtwo
  5. Rayquaza
  6. Gengar
  7. Gyarados
  8. Tyranitar
  9. Umbreon
  10. Espeon

My List:

  1. Mew
  2. Umbreon
  3. Espeon
  4. Suicune
  5. Raikou
  6. Entei
  7. Absol
  8. Lugia
  9. Ho-oh
  10. Team Rocket

Johto is definitely my favorite.

8
  1. Blastoise
  2. Pikachu
  3. Rayquaza
  4. Typhlosion
  5. Lugia
  6. Mewtwo
  7. Mew
  8. Umbreon
  9. Gengar
  10. Espeon

My List:

  1. Gengar
  2. Blastoise
  3. Pikachu
  4. Venusaur
  5. Umbreon
  6. Mew
  7. Dragonite
  8. Rayquaza
  9. Lugia
  10. Alakazam
9

Magikarp!?!

1 Like
10

This is a great thread idea!

Other People’s List:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Blastoise
  3. Lugia
  4. Rayquaza
  5. Typhlosion
  6. Venusaur
  7. Mewtwo
  8. Mew
  9. Gyarados
  10. Lugia

My List

  1. Kangaskhan
  2. Typhlosion
  3. Umbreon
  4. Mew
  5. Pikachu
  6. Dragonair
  7. Pichu
  8. Jolteon
  9. Lugia
  10. Ampharos
11

I’m going to share you a secret amongst us Gyarados collectors…

We all wish we could collect Magikarp too.

12

Other’s List:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Blastoise
  3. Venusaur
  4. Lugia
  5. Mewtwo
  6. Snorlax
  7. Charmander
  8. Squirtle
  9. Gengar
    10.Umbreon

My List:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Blastoise
  3. Gengar
  4. Lugia
  5. Snorlax
  6. Slowking
  7. Heracross
  8. Charmander
  9. Donphan
    10.Alakazam
13

I like this! :blush:

Other people:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Mewtwo
  3. Mew
  4. Bulbasaur
  5. Blastoise
  6. Lugia
  7. Eevee
  8. Typhlosion
  9. Kangaskhan
    10.Gengar

Me:

  1. Lugia
  2. Mewtwo
  3. Mew
  4. Dragonite
  5. Houndoom
  6. Pikachu
  7. Charmander
  8. Umbreon
  9. Rayquaza
    10.Bulbasaur
1 Like
14

Other People’s List:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Mewtwo
  3. Mew
  4. Lugia
  5. Blastoise
  6. Venusaur
  7. Gyarados
  8. Rayquaza
  9. Gengar
  10. Eevee

My List

  1. Rayquaza
  2. Ho-oh
  3. Mewtwo
  4. Mew
  5. Grovyle
  6. Staraptor
  7. Tyranitar
  8. Raikou
  9. Phanpy
  10. Lapras
1 Like
15

Others:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Mew
  3. Lugia
  4. Blastoise
  5. Dragonite
  6. Gengar
  7. Umbreon
  8. Espeon
  9. Rayquaza
  10. Venusaur

Me:

  1. Gengar
  2. Umbreon
  3. Lugia
  4. Mew
  5. Suicune
  6. Absol
  7. Salamence
  8. Flygon
  9. Ampharos
  10. Arcanine
16

Other People’s List:

  1. Non gen 1 Pakiman
  2. Crap
  3. Mainstream crap
  4. Crap x2
  5. I have no real personality Pokemon
  6. Crap x3
  7. Hyper hyped hype
  8. Some awfull eeveelution
  9. This shouldnt even be a Pokemon
  10. Crap x4

My List

  1. Gyarados
  2. Gyarados
  3. Gyarados
  4. Gyarados
  5. Gyarados
  6. Gyarados
  7. Gyarados
  8. Gyarados
  9. Gyarados
  10. Magikarp
2 Likes
17

Other peoples list:-
Charizard
Pikachu
Mew
Mewtwo
Blastoise
venusaur
Eevee/umbreon/espeon
Rayquaza

My list:-

Typhlosion
Umbreon
Salamence
Treecko
TBC
TBC
TBC
TBC
TBC
TBC

18

Not many people saying Squirtle / Charmander / Bulbasaur, but I think people’s perceptions are tainted by the fact that these are always common, non-holo cards.

The original question had the disclaimer “all rarity, set, and beauty of the card art being equal.”

Give the Gen 1 starters cards that are extremely rare, holo, and beautiful and then let’s see what they can do, shall we? :wink:

2 Likes
19

Others:

  1. Rayquaza
  2. Pikachu
  3. Blastoise
  4. Venusaur
  5. Mew
  6. Mewtwo
  7. Lugia
  8. Typhlosion
  9. Gengar
  10. Alakazam

Mine:

  1. Pikachu
  2. Zard
  3. Pikachu
  4. Zard
  5. Pikachu
  6. Zard
  7. Alakazam
  8. Gengar
  9. Rayquaza
  10. Machamp but only the iconic version with all different variants
20

Here you go, easily in my top 10 :blush:

Other people’s:

Gengar
Lugia
Mewtwo
Pikachu
Blastoise
Venusaur
Rayquaza
Evee
Umbreon
Tyranitar

Mine:

Squirtle
Bulbasar
Charmander
Blastoise
Venusaur
Alakazam
Tyranitar
Umbreon
Gengar
Gyarados
Mewtwo

1 Like