QotD: Which shiny Pokemon have a colour scheme that really doesn’t feel shiny to you and why? And which shiny one is the shiniest?

Welcome to the next Question of the Day!

The Question of the Day is a way to facilitate community discussion to help members ponder the unanswered questions of the world that are somehow relating to the hobby. Questionsj are many times open ended and up to interpretation. Feel free to post your thoughts in as much or as little detail as you’d like.

Helpful Considerations may or may not help some people focus their answer, these are blurred to not bother those who have their own ideas.

QotD Archive
Suggest future things here

Today’s Question:
*QotD: Which shiny Pokemon have a colour scheme that really doesn’t feel shiny to you and why? And which shiny one is the shiniest? *

Helpful Considerations: muddy colours, lighter colours, metallic look? This was a suggested question.

No because ugly ass green

Needs to be changed to this, please CREATURES please! You did it once, bring it back. continues to scream into the abyss

Coolest Shinies

8 Likes

5 Likes

shiny snorlax is so underwhelming!! shiny raikou for some reason does not bother me though, despite only being a minor change

2 Likes

Poliwrath was so beautiful…

9 Likes

Agreed Poliwrath does not get enough love. Such a clean, classic design.

5 Likes

Totally agree shiny Snorlax is way too subtle. Funny how shiny Raikou gets a pass even with a small change though.

2 Likes

I’m sure we have had this talk before. But, anyhow, pretty much a vast swathe of scarlet and violet pokemon are just the same. The worst pokemon I’ve ever seen for a shiny is maushold.

Guess which one is base form, guess which one is shiny. Or am I simply posting the base form twice?


11 Likes

i don’t mean any offense with this question but do you ever disagree with anyone lol. all of your comments are quoting and agreeing and restating what someone else said. no one is that agreeable (i would know, i’ve certainly tried)!! the only things i know that are this agreeable are LLMs :eye::mouth::eye:

3 Likes

12 Likes

Let me start with some of my favorite Shiny Pokémon, by quoting this post of 2 years ago, which of itself is a quote of 1.5 year prior. :sweat_smile:

I don’t think I’ll add any from gen 9 to this list above. Only one I was doubting about is Koraidon, even though I like its non-shiny colors way more:


As for my least favorite shiny Pokémon, it’s basically all Pokémon that barely change in color in their shiny forms.
Pikachu and Raichu for example; Jigglypuff & Wigglytuff; Meowth & Persian; Goldeen & Seaking; Flareon; Snorlax; and Zapdos (I only went over the gen 1 Pokémon this time).
If the difference between the regular version and shiny version is so subtle, you wouldn’t even be able to tell the difference between a shiny variant and the regular variant in the shadows or under a light in a TCG artwork, then it’s honestly a shitty shiny color imho.

Greetz,
Quuador

10 Likes

So since Lady’s fave mon is TatTar I am how regularly reminded how TERRIBLE TarTars shiny is…



How is that a improvement or something worth hunting for??






These are shinies I actually like. There’s a few others I didn’t post. Like Absol, both Raikou and Siscune have decent shines and if course Ray does too.

Talmonflame I’m up in the air about. I want to like but I’m not sure I Do


7 Likes

I love:

  • Green shinies, because they feel radioactive and truly shiny (Espeon, Mewtwo, Zygarde, etc.).
  • Blue shinies, because they usually differ a lot from the original (Psyduck, Mew, Corsola, Chi-Yu, Rapidash etc.).
  • Pink shinies, for the same reason (Wobbuffet, Heracross, Dragonair, etc.).
  • Black shinies, because they look really badass (Greninja, Rayquaza, Primal Kyogre, etc.).

I hate:

  • Lazy shinies — the ones that keep almost the same colors, just slightly faded (Gengar…).
6 Likes

They semi-made up for Gengar’s boring shiny with his mega form at least!

4 Likes

For Raichu specifically, I think the game Shiny is really disappointing as many pointed out already. I have the Pokémon Soda Pop Plush for Raichu and I’ve just convinced myself this is the shiny color scheme for Raichu.

12 Likes

Luxray is my fave car pokemon (one of the few they didn’t butcher).

I have not found a shiny of it in game yet but I should try fir one in Pokemon Arceus .

2 Likes

That’s amazing
The diamond remake? I got that game spent a hour on it and just couldn’t. Took it to a game shop and swapped it for Arceus. I haven’t gone shiny hunting on that game but I have in other.

1 Like

every letter of unown should be a different color in its shiny form. That would make it cool. Because no matter what color shiny you make it otherwise, its just unown.

3 Likes

Ahhhhh ok the old diamond lol not the new garbage thing they released.

Talking about shines gives me flash backs to chaining :joy:

1 Like

I’ll have to put that in unpopular opinions :joy:. Thanks for the suggestion lol

1 Like