Hi guys - got a no damage ninetales, first one I’ve had - looking to sell it as I only really collect only sealed product and some PSA 9/10 stuff and this is pretty beat up, I’d say PSA 5 quality. What do you think is the market value for it?
I see a really terrible copy sold for $75 on ebay, and other than that, nothing…and only two are listed - a PSA 5 with what seems like a very high price, and a PSA 9 (which is not close to my condition). Thanks!
I dunno, but when I see awesome cards like that in damaged condition I salivate. let me know what the consensus ends up being haha
If PSA 5 quality, I would say around $150, but it could surprise you at auction. I would definitely list at 0.99 and let it ride. You could pull in a surprisingly large amount for rare errors like that. Very few of them out there.
Good advice I just might do that.
if you do put it up for auction please pm me a link to it 
The one that went for $75 was mine, it had a ton of interest and sold quickly even while being water damaged. So for sure around the ~$150 mark imo.
I’d say an ungraded 5 quality should bring 2-300.
played condition goes for $100 easy. A 5 is worth way more than $150. I would put it up for $399 OBO
I was going to place the value between $250.00 and $275.00 myself.
There was actually another copy listed on eBay (PSA 5-ish Condition). That listing was active for MONTHS at $500.00 OBO. The seller finally started dropping the price to $450.00, $300.00, and $275.00. It finally sold for $275.00. However, I can’t see you having any trouble getting $250.00-ish for that card!
I’d actually discourage an eBay Auction… These cards don’t seem to do well via Auction. I’ve been able to pick-up a few PSA Graded Copies (5 and 6) for Sub-$200.00 via eBay Auction. And those weren’t flukes - both good listings with a good ending-date. Granted, those purchases were awhile ago now (last summer). Personally, I would go the BIN Route!
I bought the $275 one during an Ebay promotion. I’m in the market for 2 more (any condition). So if you list for $250 it will sell.
I have an ungraded 7 quality but just can’t accept it won’t get graded.
Ditto Gary. Mine is also similar quality 6-7 and it was always a card I heard about when I was a kid. It was next on the list after the prerelease raichu among legendary cards growing up, so I’m still very disappointed that it will not grade.
Does BGS grade them with the no damage classification?
Good question. I don’t know for sure but I’ll bet we find out soon;)