Just picked this absolute BEUTY up off eBay. Was able to negotiate the price down quite a bit and both the seller and I agree, this could easily, EASILY, fetch a PSA 9 if regraded. Aside from centering I’m really not sure why it got an 8.5. Cant wait to send it in for a regrade and attempt a 9, but regardless I’m just inlove with this card and for the price? It was a steal!
I’ve gone over it extensively to see if anything was scratched or any print dots but you could be right! I honestly don’t mind the 8.5, would just always appreciate a higher grade. Very thankful to even have something like this in my collection
Ahh!! I feel very luck then haha, i gotta be honest once I saw it I was like “man there’s no way that can’t be graded again, what a beauty.” It was actually a little hard to get the seller to agree to sell it I’m glad I could share it with e4! Really love this forum
hi mate, what’s your strategy here re: regrade? Are you planning to crack the case or just send it in for regrade service?
I’ve cracked a number of cases over time and learned that PSA are pretty consistent. I know people are always looking for that diamond in the rough, letting their bias tell them the card is surely a grade higher (especially me). There are so many things that can be hard to pick up on with regards to surface, it can be hard to truly know what’s holding a card back from a higher grade.
I think with an 8.5 you’ve probably got a solid shot. Personally would recommend cracking the case to remove all PSA’s bias too would love to see a follow up regardless!
Thanks! Appreciate the kind words, yea I was debating between cracking the case and sending it in or leaving it in the case and sending it in. I spent a lot of time looking through all the available 8.5s I was able to find before purchase and while this one looked the best, I still take regrading very seriously. I’ve been collecting for years & have only ever regraded cards when I was confident enough to spend the money on the regrade. I have a jewelers loop & overhead light I use for every card I get, & I try to get as many second and third opinions as possible before making this kinda decision. If it doesn’t come back a 9 it’s not a problem! Still love the card, but definitely worth a shot! Hopefully I can post some pics once I send it off and get the results back!