eBay seller listed this Yokohama Treecko as LP

I just got this in the mail from a 100% seller rating 1k sails items seller. They listed at Lighltly Played, but found this on the card.

The original listing does not highlight the crease but it’s moderately present in one pic.

My concern is that selller or someone else tried to increase/restore the card and passed it off as LP. For the price I paid I wouldn’t have minded if they were up front about the condition. I’ve contacted the seller to at least get clarification.

I really don’t mind damaged cards, but I don’t like the dishonesty. Some questions:

  1. Does this look like at least a legit card?2.
  2. Does the crease look natural or has it been restored somehow?
  3. Should I leave a negative review or take the L as it’s at least hopefully a real card that I got for a decent price?

If the price you actually paid was still very good even for the condition that it was actually in i personally wouldnt bother doing anything because it was still great just not mega great.

From what I’ve seen from random Instagram videos, if they really wanted to repair that crease, it would probably look a lot more subtle (this doesn’t seem like a difficult-to-repair crease from what I’ve seen). Do the folds/ridges on the crease look flat? I imagine a crease like that should naturally have peaks/valleys. If everything looks a bit compressed, maybe there was some attempt to flatten it.

I would not consider a crease like that to be Lightly Played, but it has great eye appeal as a binder copy. If you got the card for a decent price even in this condition, then I wouldn’t do anything.

Attempts at restoration (alteration) look a lot better than this. I doubt someone tried to alter it.

Another vote for “if you are happy with the price you paid given it’s actual condition, keep it”

It would be an easy return if you wanted to go that route, just do an INAD within 2 days of receiving the card