Biggest misgrade you’ve ever seen?

What is the biggest misgrade you’ve ever seen? Just a card that should not have received that grade? Either too high or too low of a grade?

5 Likes

At a card show I saw an either psa 8 or psa 9 ho oh ex from unseen forces which had a huge crease across the card under the right light. I pointed it out to the vendor who seemed genuinely surprised by it and removed the card from his display.

3 Likes

According to reddit, everything psa touches

11 Likes

I mean I sent a sun damaged card in and PSA gave me a 9.

3 Likes

PSA 10 Black Star Promo Venusaur. Pop 8 at PSA 10. Card definitely had scratches on the Holo. I messaged the seller and he said it was originally a PSA 6 and he cracked it in hopes of a 8 but it got a 10 I stead and he sold it last year to a guy in Australia

2 Likes

Oh wow. I’m curious how it got a 10 from a 6?

28 Likes

You guess is as good as mine. It was originally a Buy It Now for 25k. Final sell ending up being 12.5k he payed for the grade not the card

1 Like

Gotta be this one

9 Likes

Not grade, but name. I will never forgive CGC. This is madness.

26 Likes

I got a kick out of this lol

1 Like

The creases totally add to the card appeal of of the ancient mew. Makes it more ancient.

Finally it’s at home.

My chickens attacked me when I offered them the card, so I guess they know I was trying to feed them with a fake bug.


12 Likes

The card is a wild mis label but the chicken is absolutely adorable

1 Like

8 Likes

Holy shit that’s brutal.

Obviously someone pressed 10 instead of 1 but still got thru QA.

4 Likes

I’ll never understand how something like this happens

Omg, that’s not even like just a small mistake. That’s so far from gem

What does someone even do with a slab like this? Clearly they won’t be able to see it for a PSA 10 price.