Well, if this is a pure investment perspective with no regards to preferences due to tastes, this is very similar to buying stocks.
You can put all your eggs in one basket (buying one sealed box) versus diversifying your risk by putting investments into multiple products. This is just a matter of opinion.
A better question would probably be whether or not you think product 1 will increase in value faster than product 2 + 3. However, no one can answer this for you perfectly and it will be speculation.
Another thing is that by splitting your investment into two, it means that you will need more legwork in the future to ship the items, and effectively double your logistic costs for selling the same amount of value of “product”, which is something you should take into consideration.
Personally I prefer an Expedition sealed box versus a first edition fossil box + gym challenge unlimited, but that’s due to my personal preferences as a collector.