Water starter fight - 6 (vote to eliminate one)

General
1

Hello guys and welcome to the toughest day of voting for water base form starters. For yesterday’s result as expected froakie broke treecko’s highest vote percentage share record by taking 3/4th of votes with 75% on it’s share and settled in the 5th spot. Now we have the big4 and one must unfortunately go with a :cross_mark: on it as it may not reach top3. Who is that one pokemon that is slightly undeserving in top3. Let the toughest poll begin. Here are the positions beforehand

  1. Quaxly 8. Popplio 7. Sobble 6. Oshawott 5. Froakie 4. ???

eforumwater-froakie
eforumwater-froakie1152×633 81.6 KB

  • Squirtle
  • Totodile
  • Mudkip
  • Piplup
0 voters
1 Like
2

Tossup for me between voting for Mudkip and Totodile, but I started with Totodile in ZA … so some recency bias here :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

1 Like
3

not gonna lie all 4 are tremendous here and voting one doesn’t mean it is bad but just mean we have little bit extra love towards others. For me squirtle goes same it is the last starter i chose in kanto games (first being bulbasaur my boi always) and i actually never chose in kalos games but the time i used squirtle it is actually very good but for remaining three (i didn’t play za yet) totodile is the middle pick of me for johto games, mudkip is the first pick in hoenn and same for piplup in sinnoh. So voted squirtle only because of this but if there is a chance of sending all four top i would have done that.

1 Like
4

Time to use emergency Draco Meteor and hope Piplup catches it.

Whatever happens you’re still part of best starter evolution line in Sinnoh. :smiley:

1 Like
5

If froakie’s nixed, then Piplup must die!
:sob:

2 Likes
6

Seeing the votes now the future for the best water starter totodile doesn’t look that bright :thinking:

4 Likes
7

Had the same feeling indeed, although not too surprising.

But tbf, I’m glad my personal top-4 is at least the collective top-4, even if the order might differ a bit. That’s already better than the Grass starters. :wink:

Greetz,
Quuador

2 Likes
8

Hope the grass teens would get alike with your opinions making a redemption for grass base forms. :slight_smile:

1 Like
9

I can’t even confirm who is best here all are tremendous actually. But totodile could make in top3.

10

I’m not worried about totodile making it in top 3, i’m worried about what happens after that :new_moon_face:

3 Likes
11

I’m noting down everyone who votes Piplup, don’t talk to me or my son ever again /j

12 Likes