Hello, I have the opportunity to buy a GS Charizard in rough condition (probably a PSA 2) from a local guy. What would be a fair price? I am thinking around $75. Thanks so much
I’ve seen played copies go for as low as $50, but most surprisingly sell in the $100-150 range as crazy as that might sound. I think you can’t go wrong at $75. 
1 Like
I got a Garbo one for 40 bucks. There are plenty like that it’s just a matter of people actually selling their played copies
1 Like
$50-75 seems fair.
Update: Purchased it for $40
Should I grade it or sell it to troll and toad as a played card? Thoughts
PSA 2 quality is probably damaged right? If so they won’t accept it. If it’s just severly heavily played I think they will pay 35% of buy list value max so they would pay 35% of $180 or $63. Plus you’d have to ship that to them so that’s probably $5 worth of shipping and supplies off your profit as well.
1 Like
Their buylist for Charizard GS is $325. Shining Charizard is the one they are buying at 180. So 35% is $113.
Ahhh sorry sorry…thought it was a shining charizard not charizard GS. 
1 Like