The Giant Professional Grading Thread

Ah, I see, well, good luck :slight_smile:

1 Like

The PSA UK receiving center was due to open “in the back half of 2026”

Glad it’s still close, not heard anything since the original article :slight_smile:

1 Like

Can’t really see the edges very well in the photo. Looks like some whitening on the bottom left on the back, and a bit off centre on the front so maybe an 8?

Replying to my own message to update the scans.

What grade do you think these cards will receive being submitted to PSA?

Should I not send any particular card(s)? Why or how come?

600dpi scans attached as .pdf

Porygon2 1st Edition, Neo Revelation.pdf (1.9 MB)

Flareon, Skyridge.pdf (1.9 MB)

Slowking, Southern Islands.pdf (2.0 MB)

Togetic Reverse Holo, Team Rocket Returns.pdf (1.9 MB)

Magikarp Reverse Holo, Team Rocket Returns.pdf (1.9 MB)

Pikachu Reverse Holo, Emerald.pdf (1.8 MB)

Gyarados Reverse Holo, Holon Phantoms.pdf (1.9 MB)








I’m betting it’ll be $32.99 for bulk

I took a recommendation from another user here and bought some VaultX brand card savers after there was some discussion about CS1s risking damage to cards. Now that I’ve been using them for a bit, I’m a little worried that the cards will shift around since they don’t hold too tightly. Has anyone tried these other than me and noticed this? Any further experience?

I don’t think I saw this yet on this thread, but I’ll shoot my shot: has anyone bought a graded card by just looking at the scan alone? If so, were there times where the actual card exceeded the expectation of the scan? I’m asking because I’m seeing a lot of listings on a certain card that I want in a lower grade, but can’t tell if I’m overthinking things… Questions that pop up:

  • Does the scan do the cosmo holo pattern justice? I’m looking at early 2000’s Japanese cards right now. I’m wondering if some cards aren’t getting as much love because the holo looks washed out. If so, is the washed out-ness of the card due to that exactly or is it possible that the card could look nicer at different angles?
  • Are the “shinier” looking cards due to the cards natural sheen or have they been cleaned or has chemical been applied to bring out the holo? While I do like me a nice piece of shiny cardboard, I have leaned towards having something less shiny if it means it being less likely to have been altered/restored

The card I’m looking at is closer to $1000 right now, and while I hope it will get cheaper, I am considering striking now as there have been an influx of these types of cards because PSA is slowly getting through their backlog, and finding lower grades of these cards I’m afraid will be harder to find. In the end I’m looking at cracking the slab to have this card complete a mini subset I’ve been eyeing out for the last couple of months.

UPDATE: Here’s an example. Why might one card be “brighter” while the other looks “darker”. Could the scans they choose be hiding what the card might look like in real life?

Hi all - I somehow managed to pull the green RGB Mew from a 30th booster bundle. While I am trying to master set the 30th, I think I would be comfortable without having the Mew in my binder and given the rarity am leaning towards grading it. I’m UK-based and have graded with Ace previously for smaller pulls, but would like to go with a more reputable company for this card. My first instinct was PSA, but I am a little put off by the upcharges as I don’t plan to sell this (at least not in the short-term) and so am now leaning more towards Beckett or TAG. Does anyone have any thoughts? I won’t post a picture of the card, but it is pretty pristine and for these purposes (i.e. in particular from a cost perspective) I’m taking the view that it will likely 10 - and if it doesn’t, no harm done, just a nice addition to my collection.

The images PSA provides are not consistent and change quite often in terms of the lighting and exposure settings used. This can leave cards looking washed out and not doing the cosmo holo justice.

Some cards are just shinier in general, while others are naturally duller. However, this is mostly due to the actual card itself and not the copy of the card. For example, this Charmander is usually a shinier holo, whereas a completely different card may be much duller.

For example, compare the scan and picture of my Armor Fossil. It’s hard to see that it’s even a holo in the scan, but IRL, it’s much easier. That said, the Armor Fossil is still more of a dull holo compared to other cards that really pop.


The best way to judge this in your case would be to browse similar copies of the same card online. Look for actual photos, not scans. Whether raw or graded, people will usually position the card in a way that shows off the holo, which is what you’ll be doing in real life when appreciating it.

I can’t say for sure whether the 2 cards you linked have been altered or not, as it is a concern with newer certs these days. Cleaning and polishing do tend to give the impression that a card is shinier, so it’s something to be careful of. Sun fading is also something to watch out for.

6 Likes

Not at all. There is few example of mines :

So I can confirm, cards can look much nicer in hand. Usually I ask the seller for video/pictures (with and without phone flash) under a good light source.

4 Likes

Ironic, given the recent circumstances, how the two certifications you posted appear to have different slab plastics. Look at the size of the 21 and the outer ends of the bumpers inside the encapsulation.

1 Like

Thanks for this! Yeah, I wanted to chance a “less shiny” scan because maybe people will think it will look that dull. However, this person also graded several of the same card and all looked equally washed out, so I’m hoping it could just be the scanner setting and not the cards themselves (what are the odds all cards are washed out?).

And thanks for sharing your Holo Fossil! I’ve never seen that card before, but it looks sick. I have a similar card in the Mysterious Mountains Zapdos where the background is so dark that you really need to find the right angle to reveal some pretty cool cosmo holo patterns.

Amazing examples! Thanks for this! Unfortunately most of the cards I’m look at are in the PSA Vault and are newer certs. I’m hesitant that some of these cards were cleaned or polished, but I am also hopeful that they weren’t because they are PSA 5’s and below. :crossed_fingers:

I didn’t even realize that. I’m wondering if the size of the 21 matters. I think some of my slabs have different sized 21s. I’m hoping they are legit (checked the certs by hand and tried to compare the holo patterns with the scans).

These “super clones” are wild.

It will only get upcharged by PSA if you don’t send it in a high enough tier which seems unlikely considering the raw value of the card. From liquidity purposes, PSA is the most liquid with TAG being the least. For value purposes it’s BGS Black Label > BGS 10 > PSA 10 > BGS 9.5. TAG 10 can be just as high as black label or just as low as BGS 9.5. The market isn’t there fully yet for them and might never be. Will also take you the most amount of time to sell.

Paging anyone with extensive '96 Carddass prism grading experience (with PSA). I’ve been picking up Carddass prisms since early August and want to grade some. However, these things are so different from TCG cards that I have no clue what to expect in terms of grades, there are so many factors that simply don’t exist for the TCG. I’ve been looking at scans of graded cards and can’t make out any patterns, the grades just seem all over the place (do they just wing this, or roll a D10?). I’m hoping to get some insight how the following aspects affect the grades.

  1. Yellowing; the back of these cards are prone to yellowing along the edges, ranging from hardly noticeable to very severe. While I’ve tried to avoid anything with yellowing, some cards do have very mild yellowing.
  2. Nubs/bites; along the right edges the prisms will typically feature 2 small nubs (sticky outie bits image) or bites (part of the card missing image) to varying degrees. These are part of the production process, but are abnormalities from what you could consider standard measurements/integrity of a card. Can they be knocked down for ‘poor eye-appeal’?
  3. Overhanging sticker; sometimes you will see part of the prism-sticker along the edge from the back, sometimes due to being re-stuck to the back after removal, but sometimes it just seems like a poor cut? I’ve avoided these, but I’ve also stumbled on highly graded examples with the sticker peeking out along the edge. What gives?
  4. Lint; Because prisms are stickers with a layer of glue, lint frequently gets trapped along the edges. I’ve personally tried removing as much as I dare under a digital microscope, but I’ve seen 10s with very visible pieces of lint (it personally bugs me). Since I believe the lint is not a part of production, I would dock points, but that doesn’t seem to happen?

Help temper my expectations on these!

1 Like

On the heels of all of what’s happening, anyone’s guess is best. I’d argue my best card that you already know more than who will grade the card. Good luck, literally.

2 Likes

Scanner settings. I could make the card purple or white if i messed with the settings enough. Scans are not a good gauge to be honest. I would ask the seller for a photo of the card in sunlight

My latest PSA sub arrived at my doorstep today, and while checking the slabs I noticed something. There is so, so much dust/debris in these slabs. I was already annoyed by it when it happened infrequently. On this sub I reckon 1 in 4 slabs has some foreign object in it, if not more. Am seriously reconsidering grading with PSA if this is the care and attention my cards get. How does this stuff get past QA? Nevermind, don’t answer that, I just want to complain and know if other people have the same issues.

Anyone notice PSA timestamps each step now, at least on the website?

1 Like