Listen, Iām sure submitting through certain people has nothing to do with it. I used Scottās service and I had it go both ways with a few cards. I got great grades that I didnāt expect and not so great that I didnāt expect. It basically balanced out, so my overall belief is that cards are all graded fairly, but also that they are graded by humans, so there is no perfect grade or grader.
I had great results grading through Ludkins in the UK in my most recent submission. The actual grades beat almost all predicted grades so I was very pleased. So, based on my recent experience,PSA were quite generous.
I think everyone wants to vent a little or gets frustrated when receiving poor grades. I think itās natural for people to feel that way.
The only way it would change is if there was individual explanations for every graded card below 10. But that would take so much time and effort. From a customer service type of view for psa.
Itās really a matter of taste. I prefer the new PSA cases and they donāt have that distortion sleeve which is a bonus. A little narrower is preferable to me too cause I store so many. I donāt even like the sharp edges and corners. As far as stronger, I donāt see where thatās even necessary. Seems like overkill.
Bescides the BGS case, their system and grading standards suck. Not to mention the turnaround times.
I dunno, might be on to something here with these Pokemon special returns. I sent the same quality cards as I always do, and my two returns from the special were awful. 13% rate for 10s. Hell I had 2/60 for my 2nd return, abysmal. Before that, my average is just around 65% per return. Even had one card come back ārecoloredā, even though I personally picked up 5 copies when they were given out at the event (and the other 4 graded just fine). Grades seemed to be all over the place, some getting 9s and some getting 8s, without really any obvious distinction. They missed clear damage on two of my Shadowless cards and gave them 8s. No idea what happened, but this is by far the worst returns iāve had in years.
My last submission was a 1st Edition Team Rocket set submitted on behalf of a friend. After looking at them, the vast majority came back as what I expected them too. He was a very happy camper .
Some more information i also got my grades back not one 10 in the whole lot which was a shame and for sure i was like im regrading some of them and once i got them back all but one of the cards i think are spot on theres a psa 8 which i think should be a 9 other than that the rest i think are alright maybe a tad harsh on some no borderline no point in trying a regrade ( i have only ever regrading like 6/7 only 2 have come back same grade which i then sold for that grade all of my regrades have been 8s to 9s and have kept in my collect never sold a regraded cards before