Here are the results, sorted by most supported change to least supported change.
I included a weird bar-chart kind of thing showing the breakdown. Hopefully it’s intuitive without explanation.
If there’s one thing I can say, it’s that people are extremely split on whether or not any particular change is good.
GENERALLY POSITIVE (>3)
Merging CGC with CSG
Average rating: 3.86
Breakdown
Cert on the front of the label
Average rating: 3.68
Breakdown
Keeping Pristine 10 as a grade
Average rating: 3.44
Breakdown
Choosing to use gold in background of Pristine label
Average rating: 3.33
Breakdown
GENERALLY NEUTRAL (~3)
New non-Pristine label design (layout only, ignoring the color choice)
Average rating: 3.18
Breakdown
New Pristine label design (layout only, ignoring the color choice)
Average rating: 2.92
Breakdown
GENERALLY NEGATIVE (<3)
Choosing to no longer use blue in label
Average rating: 2.78
Breakdown
Upgrade all current CGC 9.5s to 10
Average rating: 2.60
Breakdown
Getting rid of Perfect 10s
Average rating: 2.44
Breakdown
Getting rid of subgrades
Average rating: 2.32
Breakdown
Continuing to use fractional (0.5) grades
Average rating: 2.27
Breakdown