I’ve been in contact with the seller and they agree the current price is outrageous, but what do you feel would be a good price?
There’s not many previous sales to compare to other than a similar miscut 1st Edition Charizard be sold for $232. I was thinking around $100 or less.
It’s not so much a lack of experience. These type of cards are generally hard to estimate a price for as they aren’t legit error cards (like the missing dmg Ninetales, for which we kinda have a going price).
Are these cards worth more than a regular base set Blastoise? Absolutely!
Are these cards worth the same as a University Magikarp and FanClub Eevee? Absolutely not!
People need to get away from thinking just because a card is misprinted it must be worth a fortune. I think it is fair to ask an extra because of it but I personally don’t think that they are worth spending more than 100$ on them. At least I couldn’t do it without bad conscience… And by the way I prefer the second one also, simply because I’ve never seen it this misaligned and the condition appears to be a lot better. If I recall correctly somebody on this site has a card similar to the first one, maybe you are better off trying to work something out with him.
I have the card listed at an outrageous price because I have no idea how much it is actually worth. I don’t want to list it for 150 bucks and then find out someone would have paid 400 for it. Not that I was expecting that, but as I have no knowledge of cards like this I wanted to be safe. Anybody who was legit interested in the card would message me. Like you have. I would have fallen off my chair if someone even offered me half of the stupid price I listed.
I suppose I will respond to your eBay message here @cheesypoof999
For 50 USD I’d rather just keep it, I am not strapped for cash and I am just as happy to keep it
