How would you rank the video games

I specifically go for a ranking here, as a poll will restult in a tie between Gen 1, 2 and 3 which isn´t that interesting.

Only take into account the main series, so R/B to S/V (9 Gens).

For me it would go like;

Gen 2 (something about the vibe that is just replayable more than any other)
Gen 1
Gen 3
Gen 6 (not the best, but very cohesive)
Gen 5 (when talking B/W 2)
Gen 7
Gen 4
Gen 9
Gen 8 (I really didn´t like what they did here).

emerald platinum and hgss above all else

8 Likes

Yeah, I have to admit that in my ranking I use the D/P games. Never played Platinum.

I’ll simplify my ranking like this. As the generations increase, my playtimes typically decrease.

4 Likes

Same goes for me, with Gen 6 as a positive outlier. Which is weird, since, in my opinion, the first 3D entry is still the best.

You should throw the two Legends games in as well since they are confirmed by GameFreak to be mainline games.

I think my answers depend on how I’m playing the games. I would rank the games differently depending on if I’m doing a standard playthrough or if I’m completing the national Pokedex (which I have done in every game).

For example, Gen 3 would be near the top of the list for a standard playthrough but near the bottom for Pokedex completion.

1 Like

Ruby >= Gold > everything else.

First one I owned, second one I played, and then nothing really hit the same after.

The rest I have played but they truly blend into one.

Bold take but I don’t think the games are really all that good.

1 Like

Kinda impossible to rank when the last time I played Yellow, Gold/Silver and Ruby/Sapphire were when they came out lol. Then I think I played FireRed/LeafGreen and maybe Diamond/Pearl on an emulator which means I remember even less and didn’t get the whole experience.

So really I can only rank:
Scarlet & Violet (Scarlet)
Sword & Shield (Shield)

I guess you could throw in Legends: ZA as well. Probably better than SWSH but the DLC was horrendously boring.

1 Like

After much thought I dont think I can rank them. Each one has something specific I love about it!

HeartGold/SoulSilver: 10/10 Perfection

Ruby/Sapphire/Emerald: 9.5/10 Legendary

Gold/Silver/Crystal: 9.25/10 Amazing

Green/Red/Blue/Yellow: 9/10 Goated

FireRed/Leafgreen: 9/10 Just as Good

Diamond/Pearl/Platinum: 8/10 Solid

Black/White: 7/10 Not as Solid

Pokemon rangers slams btw

4 > 2 > 3 > 6 > 1 > 9 > 8 > 7 > 5 if you consider remakes to be part of the generation they’re remade in (i.e. HGSS is gen 4)

2 > 6 > 1 > 4 > 3 > 9 > 8 > 7 > 5 if you consider remakes to be part of the generation they’re remaking (i.e. HGSS is gen 2)

1 Like

Play them again mate. You won´t be disappointed.

Since you never specified Main Line Games (Only ranking games I’ve personally played)

PMD: Explorers of Sky
Heart Gold/Soul Silver
PMD: Red Rescue Team
PR: Shadows of Altima
Black/White
Black 2/White 2
Legends Arceus
Pokemon Conquest
PR: Guardian Signs
Pokemon Platinum
Pokemon Ranger
Pokepark Wii
Pokepark 2
Unite
PMD: Explorers of Time
Pokemon Emerald
Legends ZA
X/Y
Ultra Sun/ Ultra Moon
Cafe Remix
Rumble
Sun / Moon
Ruby/Sapphire
Diamond/Pearl
TCG Pocket
Fire Red/ Leaf Green
Magikarp Jump
Sword/Shield
Scarlet/Violet
My Pokemon Ranch
Masters EX
Battle Revolution
Puzzle League
Brilliant Diamond/Shining Pearl

2 Likes

Something like this maybe

2 Likes

I know this is unpopular & dismissed as genwunner, but i really think gen 2 takes the cake. They hadn’t ironed everything out yet re special/phys split, many pokemon are locked until the post-game, and the level curve could’ve been improved, but the leap from gen 1 was astounding. The game was incredible given the technology at the time, the music is peak, the sprites are awesome, and the surprise Red final boss felt like the perfect endcap to the gen 1 & 2 saga.

Emerald was also great and i love the battle frontier, but the leap in improvement from gen 1 to gen 2 was much larger than from gen 2 to gen 3 imo

All of that said, I never played gen 5 or anything post ORAS…

1 Like

Gen 1
Gen 3 remakes
Gen 5
Gen 3
Gen 4
Gen 2

Didn’t play Gen 6+

Not in a punitive way, but I think this is missing out. The more recent games are genuinely a fun experience if imperfect

Oh, it’s not on purpose I didn’t play them. But pure financial decision making. I didn’t want to spend the money buying a 3DS to play Pokémon. Neither did I want to spend money to buy a Switch to play Pokémon. Because they would all up like my Xbox; just there but barely used because just no time to sit down and play.

One day… when scriptkiddies made it easy to work on some decompile thing on PC/Android I will give them a try.

1 Like