What card deserved better

I disagree with a few things around this Xatu. First, as a holo it would have been so awesome. Also, it should have featured in Neo Discovery where it’s actually on the pack, and box art. Still a cool card though.

10 Likes

Same set but my complaint is about Omastar.

Overall I think Neo Discovery is a great set but that Magnemite has always felt misplaced, in my perfect world Magnemite swaps places with Neo Revelation Shuckle ( both become common cards ) while uncommon Neo Discovery Omastar gets promotion to both rare and holofoil rare.

5 Likes

I wish they made the McDonald’s mew sunset promo in a holo. It’s too good

1 Like

Should have been a holo rare:

Should have been facing the viewer or somehow a bit more dynamic. Although I think I understand the direction they were going for with this art.

Should have been related to Team Rocket in the artwork:

15 Likes

Yeah, the Magnemite is a weird one. I do love it. Seems like they were really promoting the Steel-type.

It’s pretty cool when paired with it’s evo.

5 Likes

Agree on the Golem. That was actually one of my favourite cards to pull even though it isn’t even a rare card.

5 Likes

Omastar was consistently passed over in favor of Kabutops

1 Like

6 Likes

Heavy on the fossil golem. Also, after a certain point (post ADV), it was decided Golem would not be getting holo rares (with some exceptions, like EX cards and the goofy one in Sun and Moon). Probably because it would be stepping on Tyranitar’s toes, at that point.

Which is a shame because some of these really call for the cosmos treatment.

5 Likes

I’ve checked the bottom right rarity symbol on my Golems more times than I’d like to admit thinking they’re non holo rares. You’d think I’d remember at some point but it just seems so wrong as an uncommon.

3 Likes

@Nightvulture Base set Mewtwo was such a let down. He dominated the original games, peak Legendary pokemon, and they give him 60HP with a 10+ attack…

Also Fossil Golem is so hard to beat! Such an odd choice making him uncommon instead of Rare.

Arcanine Base set deserved better.

At least make him a NH Rare. He went from being potential Legendary pokemon status to the same rarity as Seel.

19 Likes

Very good one too. I think along with Fossil Golem and Jungle Rhydon these are the weirdest ones. Would be interesting to hear the why about it.

1 Like

As much as I agree about Golem, they may have ran out of rare slots, so they had to settle for the next best thing. You can only have so many of one type of rarity to keep the pull rates somewhat balanced. To many rares would start to mess with the consistency of pulling other rares. He did deserve the holo treatment though. They already had 15 rares out of 62 cards total, and another 15 of those were holo variants of the same rares. Though the way fossil was set up I doubt it would have made to much of a difference adding a 16/32 out of the 62 in terms of pull rates. They may have considered it at one point during development and just decided against it to try and constrain themselves with such a small set.

Dragonair from base set would have been beautiful as a holo rare and I think she deserved it with her art, and so would have Lass/Pokemon Breeder/Pokemon Trader, but they were probably again trying to constrain themselves with the number of holos within the set due to pull rate mechanisms (not doing duplicate non-holos for base set like they did for jungle/fossil/ect.). I agree with smpratte, Arcanine got jipped.

4 Likes

I came here to say this. Nothing terribly wrong with the art or anything, but wow what a weak card or what was (at the time) the most legendary 'mon in the series.

3 Likes

Absolutely agree on Arcanine too, he got the numbers though. Mewtwo probably couldve been reimagined with 80hp and psychic doing 20+10 for each energy on the defending pokemon for 1 psychic energy. A little more bulk and a reasonable attack wouldve changed mewtwos outlook

3 Likes

I think the problem is that it is a basic Pokémon. They were already too strong as it is.

1 Like

Yeah, Mewtwo was overpowered for an entirely different reason as far as the tcg is concerned. Barrier was broken af.

2 Likes

Indeed. It was actually pretty powerful. It just didn’t look powerful. The same can be said about a card like Electabuzz. Looks weak, until you see what it does.

2 Likes

Seel being the Pokémon version of Gary Oak is its own kind of legendary.

IMG_4182

3 Likes

In comparison to chan and electabuzz, they towered over mewtwo. Terrible design oversight