Here is a good thread by @jkanly but to give you my perspective, ultra pro (deck protector?) sleeves = KMC Super Series W version (without logo), Dragonshields may be similar but I’ve never tried those, I find the thickness of ultra pro & KMC W, tend to damage corners and don’t prefer using them.
I’ve never tried KMC Hyper matte Clears
If you want penny sleeves that you don’t have to cut anymore, similar strength/thickness but fits in binders you’d want the mayday games 'almost-a-penny" sleeves.
I’m still looking for some clear sleeves that can fit in binders but are thicker than penny sleeves but thinner than ultra pros.
Dimensions are never advertised correctly, that’s why its important for these threads, as the mayday sleeve dimensions are bigger than the ultra pro premium sleeves yet are smaller in reality.
Both the penny and Ultra Pro Premium Sleeves gets caught when inserting them into the ‘Monster’ binder. everything else fits in smoothly.
Ultra Premium Sleeves is a tight fit on modern binders for me but works as @nickofturl has shown.
What they look like in binders.
