pikachutcg:
pokecollectoramy:
So it seems like without tears and discoloration it is tough to get a 1, obviously different from PSA where one large crease is an automatic 1, even if the rest of the card looks like a 10. Very interesting to say the least. What do we all think? According to their stated grading scale this Zard definitely should be a 3 or 3.5, it all comes down to how we as collectors accept this different scale
Honestly i think it’s better this way, there’s so many cards that would auto get a 1 at PSA but not even be that bad, I remember Gary posting this and thought it was pretty silly of a grade.
However maybe they should reword there grades… Like that Charizard is a 3.5 okay that’s fine but then its called VeryGood+ ? I don’t think that card is in ‘very good’ condition does anyone else?
Yep, that psa 1 1st Ed Venusaur looks wayyyy better on appeal than my psa 6 one lol. Also the wording is consistent with everyone else, even if it doesn’t make sense. A PSA 3 is also “very good” on the label
1 Like