Base Set Error Packs from Ex-WOTC Employee

Not sure why I didn’t get any notifications, but this is a very interesting post.

I have not personally ever seen a Base set pack with the red tape. I have seen it for other packs, mainly modern ones.

I have never seen use of the sealed case tape being used on a pack ever. That part seems incredibly strange to me.

These packs look fairly convincing but I would love to know if the case tape was ever a real method utilized. I would love to see some high res scans.

I did some initial analysis and my big red flags with these are:

  • Some colors look way off
  • The top/bottom crimps look about 10% more dense than normal ( There are more crimp lines than normal )
  • The vertical crimps are very square in appearance instead of rectangular
  • Tape font and punctuation does not match other samples from a sealed case of Base set blisters ( you can buy stop tape online amazon )

Below are pictures of the packs in question followed by a graded PSA short crimp shadowless example.

10 Likes

Does anyone have a photo of an authentic sealed WOTC booster box case? You can purchase the stop tape online, but a few of the letters and punctuation vary. If it matches an authentic case tape it may help authenticate it.

4 Likes

Hey guys,

This is Jack with Loose Packs, I appreciate the conversation, questions, and concerns about the packs. These are technically on consignment with us for a personal friend. He is the one who made the connection with the ex-WOTC employee. These packs were a tiny part of the lot that was picked up that included multiple booster boxes, a sealed case of Legendary Collection Blisters, dozens of WOTC League blisters, and loads of not as cool factory error packs (crimp errors, alignment errors, burnt crimps from being pressed too hard, etc. Essentially packs meant for disposal).

I was skeptical about these packs as well, and if anyone has any additional information about them I’d love to hear it. I spoke with Rusty about them briefly and it’s not something he has ever seen either. Obviously the red tape we have seen before (though not on Base packs) but the stop tape is a weird one. So I had my doubts. But there are things about it that simply cannot be replicated. The biggest tell for me is that the crimping goes over the tape. If it was done by someone with nefarious intentions after the fact the tape would either go over the crimp or that person would have to crimp the packs again, resulting in multiple crimps.

The only thing I could think of is the WOTC employees taped together the rolls of pack arts for faster and more seamless work on the factory line. Whether it is a symptom of laziness or ingenuity, I think we can all understand the desire to speed up an otherwise mundane job in any way possible. Otherwise I’m not sure how they came about.

Mid post edit: I just looked at them again, the venusaur + charizard pack is overlapped, like they laid a new roll on top of the end of an old roll. So the top half of the pack actually has two booster packs. One inside the other. The bottom half is only the one pack. It’s very interesting.

If anyone has any more information on these I’d love to hear it. We’ve never seen anything like it and from the people I’ve spoken with, neither have they.

12 Likes

Any chance you can provide high resolution scans of one?

The short crimp shadowless pack looks like you can see the cards inside, has anyone been able to peek at the card?

The font and punctuation on the tape seem unusual. I haven’t been able to find another WOTC stop tape that uses a Franklin Gothic-like font. The “g” in particular.

Here is an example of a product from that era with the normal stop tape.

8 Likes

The short crimp shadowless you can indeed see inside. I was able to shift the cards slightly and they are actually shadowless and there is a holo Venusaur lol. When I get back into my office I’ll take some higher resolution photos. Anything in particular you’d like me to take?

8 Likes

Very nice catch :eyes:

2 Likes

Crazy! If possible a better quality pic of this would be interesting to see.

One thing I notice in that pic is a bit of iridescent shine to the foil. I have been able to cause that appearance when applying heat to a wrapper. It may be another detail to check for if there are excessive amounts of it.

8 Likes

I noticed the same “g” on some WOTC MTG cases…but the font still looks slightly different - less condensed.

Screenshot from an 8 year old Alpha Investments video.

Another on a more recent case (I think)

3 Likes

OP took a screenshot of our website, those photos are very high definition. I will upload all of the full quality ones

7 Likes

Are you able to take an up close picture of the last pack where the “m” is in “damaged”? It looks like it’s printed on the pack itself but it would be useful to know if the tape is just missing the white part for some reason.

1 Like

Eating dinner but I will after. It is not on the pack, though, I did check after you (or someone else) mentioned it earlier in the thread. The white part of the tape has torn off and it is clear but definitely still tape

3 Likes

Difficult to capture on camera but I did my best with our floodlights to capture the texture and reflection showing it is the tape. Also tried to take a photo of the top of the pack where you can see it is two booster packs wrapped in one! The bottom is not, which is extra cool

9 Likes

I was able to find one other example where similar stop tape appears on a modern pack.

I still don’t quite understand how a partial pack would ever end up inside another pack during manufacturing.

You could in theory buy some of the tape, cut a booster pack, slide it into another pack, glue it, tape it. Only difficult part would be to get matching crimp marks as seen on the stop sign on the back flap.

https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonTCG/comments/1joln68/found_error_pack_for_journey_together/

5 Likes

I can provide some additional context here.
Hello again everyone, let’s see if I can remember how this forum works. :slightly_smiling_face:

WotC designs cards and does the prepress work.
WotC hires a print facility to manufacture the physical cards.
The print facility is in the business of printing things, and they purchase various supplies from other companies.
The ink comes from another company.
The sheets of unprinted cardstock come from another company.
The booster wrappers (which are called “flow wrap”) come from another company.

Originally, all the WotC booster wrappers were supplied by a company named Spruyt in Belgium, but that company went out of business at the end of 1994, so they weren’t used for Pokémon.
After Spruyt, all WotC booster wrappers were supplied by a company named Vitra.
Vitra is still supplying WotC with booster wrappers today, though it’s possible WotC could have additional suppliers now.
Booster wrappers are made by the Vitra Creavit team.
Vitra was purchased by Korozo near the end of 2019, and the company name changed slightly to VitraPack.

I think booster wrappers are made on a web press using long continuous rolls of material, instead of a sheet fed press like the cards.
Here’s a picture of Magic The Gathering 4th Edition booster wrappers from 1995, to help you understand.
Pokémon booster wrappers were made the same way.
(hmm, how do I add a picture… ah, I think it’s this button.)

In that picture, you can see the same artwork across each row, with different rows having different artwork.
Magic The Gathering 4th Edition had 5 different artworks for booster wrappers, so the art repeats after 5 rows.
It would be MUCH longer than what’s shown here. This is just a small piece.
This picture is 5 packs wide, but in later years they were able to make it wider in order to print more booster wrappers in the same time.

After printing it like this, it goes through a slitter to separate it into rolls that are only 1 pack wide with alternating artwork.
Here’s an example showing Magic The Gathering Visions & Weatherlight booster wrappers from 1997.
Visions & Weatherlight had the same artwork on every pack, so you won’t see alternating art here.

Again, this is just a small sample. The length of material is quite long on each roll, so that it doesn’t have to be replaced as frequently during use.

I’ve seen the red tape quite a few times on Magic The Gathering booster packs, and I’ve heard that it’s applied near the end of each roll to signal to the machine operator that the roll of booster wrapper material will need changed soon.
I’ve also seen black tape.
This is applied during manufacturing of the booster wrapper material, not at the TCG print facility.
Some of the Pokémon examples above, show the printing “on top of” the red tape.
The facility that creates the booster wrappers, wouldn’t have much need for Stop Tape as far as I know, because it’s a large wholesale transaction between industry partners, and shipped on a pallet, not inside little retail cardboard cases.

The booster material itself starts as a clear plastic.
The booster image is printed on the inside of the clear plastic, like Picasso painting on a glass window.
In this picture, I’m holding a roll of this clear booster material that’s been printed with the booster image for German Magic The Gathering Portal from 1997.

The next step after this, is to apply the shiny reflective silver (or gold) coating that you see inside the booster wrappers.

To show you that this info applies to Pokémon, and is still applicable today, here’s a couple pictures of a Pokemon Trick or Trade 2024 wrapper (not a WotC product), which I opened a few days ago on Halloween 2025.
This clearly shows the clear plastic material, with printing inside, which is covered by a silver coating.
On the crimp area, you can see that the printed ink stayed stuck to the silver coating, while the clear plastic peeled away.

It was a pretty good opening. I got the most expensive card in the set, if anybody wants to watch.
https://youtu.be/jau9BT2Lbtw?si=C6hHTJRBCV-1YY9x

I haven’t seen the Stop Tape on a booster pack before, but maybe it could happen at the TCG print facility (or Pack Out Facility) while they’re switching from an empty roll of booster wrappers to a new roll, or if a roll breaks in the middle and they have to patch it together to use the rest of the roll.
If you were patching two pieces of material together, you’d overlap it to the correct pack dimension, and tape it.
The facility which is packaging the cards into boosters and putting them into boxes and cases, would have Stop Tape handy.

Tavis King

15 Likes

Fantastic write up @cataclysm80 as always, I’ve included a couple modern examples of Stop tape packs I have found underneath.




These and vintage red tapes are pretty cool, makes it even better to me that someone probably did it to save time and came out with these anomalies.

4 Likes

7 Likes