What-If: Suppose you lost all memories of Pokemon and collecting

Suppose you woke up from a coma and lost every memory of Pokemon, collecting, and your collection. When you arrive back home, you find that you must have been an avid Pokemon card collector.

  • How would you approach learning about your collector self?
  • Do you think you would enjoy learning how to collect again?
  • If you continued collecting, do you think you would be interested in the same things? Remember, those core collecting memories are gone.
  • If you did not continue collecting, what would you do with your collection?
  • Would you expect your family or friends to help you learn this part of you?
5 Likes

I would walk into my house and be like ā€œdamn, I’m cool as hellā€ :smiling_face_with_sunglasses:

20 Likes

Hard question, I honestly don’t know if I would continue collecting cause of the fact I woudn’t have any Pokemon related memories. My memories is what keeps me collecting, I’d guess I would sell everything and buy something else lol

7 Likes

I would probably turn around to sell all of my cards and games and then invest/save the proceeds of doing so. There’s no reason to keep around a bunch of tchotchkes that mean nothing to me, especially not ones that can improve one’s financial situation so easily.

…It would be nice to consider that I’d get reintroduced to it through my family and friends. But even then I’d transition to having cards to play with since Gen 3/4 stuff will no longer have the same personal connection that it once did.

8 Likes

I would have no interest in collecting if my childhood and adult memories of PokƩmon were gone.

10 Likes

Obviously you never know for sure how you’d feel, but I’ve always been a collector of other franchises. While I’ve sold off a large chunk of this stuff now and honed in on Pokemon, my collecting tendencies certainly run deep. So, I almost certainly would see my collection and think to myself, ā€œthis must have meant a lot to meā€ and ponder the feelings of my past self I don’t remember. Maybe feel sadness for this great collection I have no memory of. I’m a very sentimental person like that. Would I keep everything? Probably not, a lot of the merch I have takes up a lot of space. I think I’d try to do the research on what I had, but hard to know if I’d ever reconnect with my collection without my childhood love of Pokemon.

1 Like

No idea.

Re-educating oneself about Pokemon collecting from the ground up in 2026 sounds like a supremely miserable affair.

Absolutely. Likely an increased interest in holographic vintage promos.

:atm_sign:

A little perhaps.

No idea. I’ve been collecting all kind of stuff since being a 5 y.o. kid. Both collecting and PokĆ©mon are such a big parts of my life, so I honestly wouldn’t even know if I’d still be ā€˜me’ if all the PokĆ©mon and collecting related memories are gone.

It also would be very weird coming home to multiple collections, like minerals/fossils; twisty puzzles; Yu-Gi-Oh cards; and most noticeably my many PokƩmon products scattered around my work/hobby room, all gone from my memory.

It’s a really hard thing to grasp and hypothetically answer, since I honestly wouldn’t even know what to think.
Not to mention the additional confusion of having gaps in your memory in general will also be a huge impact on yourself as a person I’d imagine.

Probably, although maybe not PokĆ©mon in particular. But collecting in general is likely part of my DNA, considering how much I’ve done it in my life, haha.
But again, very hard to answer if all those memories are completely gone. Especially since starting collecting as a kid and starting collecting as an adult are two different things.

Also hard to say. Since I do come home to a house full of multiple collections, my interest would likely be going first to those. Starting by researching what they are and such.
Because of that it would be difficult to look for something else to collect.

If, hypothetically, all the collections themselves would be gone alongside my memories, then I’d likely be collecting something completely different down the line. Perhaps.
Ugh, although I have a lively imagination, thinking about something as abstract as this kinda gives me a headache, haha.

At first keep them, hoping a cure could be found for my memory loss. From the sizes of the collections, I would know it was a big part of my life, so because of that it also wouldn’t feel right to sell anything without trying absolutely everything I can to get my memory back.

But after a few years without finding any cure for the memory loss, no doubt in the mean time already researching a bit about all the collections and realizing how much money especially the PokĆ©mon card collection is worth, and no doubt finding other interests over time, I’d likely try to sell a lot of it to finance other aspects in life.

Definitely. If I can’t remember anything and they remember all of it (from their perspective), I defintely would have asked them a lot about it. Who wouldn’t?
Sure, there would be numerous of things my family and friends wouldn’t know, but then I’d at least know:

  1. I’d have ā€˜the largest Pikachu collection in the world’ (which wouldn’t be true, since I’m 3rd place rn afaik, but I know some of my family members and friends would have remembered it like that :sweat_smile: )
  2. I absolutely loved PokƩmon from the day it was released and have collected it as a kid and watched the cartoon/anime a lot.
  3. I got my house by selling a bunch of PokĆ©mon cards (I’m kinda curious how I’d remember this aspect myself - I’d likely remember having the money on the bank from a certain moment in time, but not how it got there. Then again, I’d have thousands upon thousands of gaps in my memory, so I guess that specific gap among the many others wouldn’t surprise me that much, tbf.)
  4. I’d know I was able to solve a Rubik’s Cube before, but now not anymore. :wink:

Also, since I use the username ā€˜Quuador’ for social media and as game names that I’d partially would remember (e.g. YouTube and Overwatch mostly. Reddit, Facebook, and Instagram likely not, since I almost exclusively use it for PokĆ©mon/Yu-Gi-Oh) and it’s very unique, I’d likely google for it and would come across all my posts here on E4, on reddit, on Instagram, on the TwistyPuzzles Forum, etc. and would probably spend hours upon hours reading what my past self has written.

Greetz,
Quuador

4 Likes

This is the answer

Screenshot 2026-02-19 at 10.30.17 AM

6 Likes

Assuming I kept the my personality traits and knowledge of my other interests I would probably jump right back into it. I’m a collector and nerd at heart (gundam. lego, video games, etc) so Pokemon would probably just feel like an extension to that.

That being said, I can imagine I would lose a lot of interest in vintage. Most of the connection to older eras has to do with personal memories and experience. Not to mention modern cards looking so good.

I would search how much they’re worth, and likely immediately sell everything.

This is a hard one to know how I would feel

  1. I love vintage Pokemon cards because I grew up with them, the anime and the gameboy games. Without that nostalgia they would be as other card games are to me now which is pretty meaningless. Albeit I do think there is something inherently cool about holo vintage Pokemon cards. I also might like the financial aspect of how sealed products are investable without knowing anything about Pokemon.
  2. If I still had my collection I may enjoy looking at it but would check the prices and see that some of this cardboard in plastic is ridiculously valuable, and the money would be worth a lot more to me than a card game I had forgotten. I would probably take the view that the value going down is a risk, than it being a replacement for traditional savings/investments and holding onto something I know nothing about
  3. It may create a new era of nostalgia for future me e.g. I don’t only have the nostalgia from being a kid but I have a nostalgic period of being at college in 2015 and collecting/selling cards on ebay as well as the times of buying reduced product from supermarkets in 2017/2018

Hmmm, how does ā€œwine, women and songā€ sound as an alternative lifestyle choice?

I think I would notice that I’m a Charizard and Pikachu fan because I have more of those cards than any other. I don’t think I would figure out that Mewtwo was one of my favorites though because I don’t have that many Mewtwo cards…and that makes me really sad.

Thats crazy to think about and also something I didn’t think I needed to prepare for just in case :rofl:

image

I would probably call them pokemans