It’s been a while since my last article… Please enjoy! 
03:17 a.m.
The phone vibrates: “Live auction, final notice!”
On the screen, a Shining Charizard #107 PSA 9 has just surpassed $5,900. You have ten seconds to decide: do you increase your bid or go back to bed?
Is this the impulse of a collector, the cold calculation of an investor, a quick maneuver of a speculator… or the daily routine of a dealer who lives by rotating inventory?
Behind every click, there’s a different mindset.
Join me in breaking down what distinguishes them, why they clash, and—most importantly—figuring out which side you play on.
1. The Collector: When Nostalgia Matters More Than Excel
A stroke of luck at seven in the morning.
You’ve been hunting second-hand forums and local fairs for months. Today, at a dusty market, a seller pulls out from a forgotten box a Venusaur Shadowless 1st Edition in almost perfect condition. Your pulse races: this means completing your 1999 Base Set at last. The price is 20% above the “eBay average”, but your finger is already hovering over your wallet. Investment? Maybe. Emotional need? Definitely.
1.1. What drives the collector?
| Motivation | Practical Example |
|---|---|
| Continuity with the past | Gathering the cards you had (or dreamed of) as a child to “recover” that era (you know, nostalgia). |
| Personal memory | Each piece tells the story of where, when, and with whom you got it. |
| Control and order | Cataloging, sleeving, aligning by Pokédex number, type, or alphabetically: bringing harmony where there was chaos. |
| Identity building | Show off your WOTC binder on social media as a statement of “this is who I am”. |
| Status | Owning a Trophy Kangaskhan or an Illustrator grants an “elite” aura among peers. |
A collector is born, not made. And to reinforce this idea, veterans like Harry L. Rinker, a collecting dean, admitted that the drive begins in childhood and never fades; it just hibernates until a new trigger—a live auction, a move, a chat with another fan—reactivates it.
1.2. Distinctive features of the collector:
-
Encyclopedic knowledge. If it’s part of the hobby that obsesses you, you know in which set Suicune first appeared, how many PSA 10 copies of Shining Magikarp exist, and which promos came with the 2000 movie premiere.
-
Peer network. Forums, private Discord and Telegram groups, trades, and meetups at conventions: the more you share, the more opportunities you have to find and acquire hard-to-get pieces.
-
Almost infinite patience. A collector can wait years for “the right card” in the right condition to appear.
1.3. Blind spots and risks:
-
Emotional overbuying. The mantra “everything will increase in price”, which surrounds many collectibles during certain times of their lives, serves as an excuse to overpay or accumulate modern material that might never appreciate—or could even depreciate.
-
Hoarding and lack of space. Rinker recounts how, upon retiring, stacked boxes stole the joy of continued buying; he had to catalog and sell before he could enjoy his collection again. I’ve experienced a similar restructuring when I realized I no longer had time to admire everything I owned.
-
Low liquidity. Selling something that feels part of you is mentally painful; sometimes you’d rather under-sell than negotiate coldly, or not sell at all even if your financial health needs it.
-
Unclear succession plan. Who will inherit your Gold Stars binder? Will your family benefit from it or would they prefer what you could get for it? Many collectors delay the answer until it’s too late.
1.4. Good practices to survive yourself:
-
Digital inventory. Photograph, record purchase price, grade, and location. Tools like Google Sheets prevent duplicate purchases and make appraising for insurance easier if needed someday.
-
Monthly/annual budget. Set a spending ceiling and respect it as much as an investor respects their price cap.
-
Periodic curation. Review every six months which pieces still “tell you something” or, at least, still make sense in your collection, and which could be sold to fund larger goals.
-
Insurance and preservation. Non-PVC sleeves, proper binders, controlled humidity, and a specific insurance policy minimize catastrophes.
-
“One in, one out” rule. An optional rule to avoid congestion: each new significant piece means selling, trading, or gifting a less important one.
1.5. When does it stop being pure collecting?
When you start setting sale target prices, comparing ROI to the S&P 500, and buying duplicates “just in case,” you’re taking a step towards the collector-investor: half passion, half alternative pension plan.
But before we see mixed profiles, let’s continue with the basics.
¿What happens when financial discipline replaces nostalgia and every purchase obeys an Excel spreadsheet?
Keep reading to discover how your mind—or your wallet—aligns with the Investor profile.
2. The Investor: when Excel rules over nostalgia
2.1. The Decisive Moment
Sunday morning. The auction for the Shining Charizard PSA 9 we saw earlier has just gone up from $5,900 to $6,200. You’ve set your cap: $6,000.
Do you click again? No; you take a deep breath, close the tab, and go back to bed.
Here lies the difference: the collector would have bid without a second thought… “What are 200 more dollars?”; you, the investor, stick to your plan at all costs.
2.2. What drives the investor?
-
ROI above romance. You trade emotions for annual revaluation percentages.
-
Investment-grade. Only the top 10% (or even 3%) of collectibles in any hobby: rare pieces, in demand, and in premium condition.
-
5-10 year horizon. You’re not looking for next month’s “pump”: unless your plan says otherwise, you’re betting on compound interest and long-term profitability.
-
Price discipline. If the bid surpasses your target price, you walk away without drama.
2.3. Distinctive characteristics of the investor
| Trait | How it translates to Pokémon TCG… |
|---|---|
| Price cap | “Charizard 1st Ed PSA 9: I won’t pay more than 24,000 $.” |
| Data tools | Pop-reports PSA, sales records, Excel with target returns. |
| Controlled diversification | 50% blue-chip vintage, 30% rare and historical promos, 20% WOTC sealed. |
| Risk management | Specialized insurance, fireproof boxes, humidity < 50 %. |
2.4. Blind spots and risks
-
Slow liquidity. Selling a Trophy Kangaskhan could take months if you’re not willing to auction it.
-
Post-hype corrections. Remember the 2021 peak, during the pandemic, with vintage Pokémon? That 1st Ed PSA 9 Charizard corrected almost 75%.
-
Opportunity cost. While you wait for your 10% annual revaluation, the S&P 500 could yield +13%, Bitcoin might do +30%, or you could have invested in a real estate cash-flow asset like a rental property or garage.
-
Frauds and restorations. A “vintage” counterfeit box or hidden scratches on a supposedly NM card could cost you thousands.
2.5. Best practices to tame the market
-
Written plan and annual reviews. Update your price cap according to new sales and market conditions.
-
Exposure cap. Never more than 10% of your total wealth in cardboard. As much as we love Pikachu, cards are still a speculative asset when you treat them as an investment.
-
Buy in blood, sell in euphoria. 2022-2023 were years of correction and less interest in Pokémon TCG. That’s when you act and put your money to work.
-
Clear exits. “I’ll sell if my annualized profit is less than 6% or if the piece doubles its market price.”
-
Network of reliable dealers. A 5% margin today is more valuable than a 10% uncertain buyer tomorrow.
2.6. When do you stop being a pure investor?
The moment you pay a premium for that perfectly centered copy “because it looks prettier in the display case,” you slide into the investor-collector role. Nothing wrong with that… as long as you don’t break your discipline.
3. The Dealer: When Business Comes Before Possession
3.1. The Other Side of the Counter
It’s 8:00 AM and you’ve just opened the blinds of your small online store. On the agenda, four routine tasks:
-
List on eBay the bulk lot of 200 Evolving Skies booster packs you bought at 60% of retail price.
-
Close the deal with your Japanese contact for a Bilingual Exeggutor from the Tropical Mega Battle CGC 8, below the average of the latest sales.
-
Package up that Moonbreon PSA 10 an investor—perhaps one of the ones who just read the previous section—bought from you yesterday.
-
Contact three new sealed product suppliers and try to buy booster boxes from the latest set.
For you, each of these items is pure inventory: it comes in, generates margin, and goes out. The dealer doesn’t get attached; they calculate.
3.2. What Moves the Dealer
-
Constant Cash Flow. You live from rotation, not from “holding”.
-
Margin Over Cost. If you’re not making at least a 5-10% margin, the deal doesn’t justify the stock risk or the time invested.
-
Speed > Nostalgia. Every day a piece sits on the shelf is dead money.
-
Supply Network. Your real talent is not collecting, but finding cheap supply before anyone else does.
3.3. Distinctive Characteristics of the Dealer
| Trait | How it translates to Pokémon TCG… |
|---|---|
| Average Purchase Cost (APC) | Bulk lots of rare cards at $0.03 to resell at $0.12 |
| Quick Rotation | Goal: Sell 70% of inventory in < 60 days |
| Tight Margins | A Pikachu Gold Star comes with an 8% margin; a modern box with 15% |
| Relationship with Grading & Auctions | Volume discounts at PSA/CGC; consignment deals with Goldin or Fanatics Collect |
| Tax Management | VAT/sales control, detailed record of cost and margins for tax purposes |
3.4. Blind Spots and Risks
-
Overexposure to New Product. If The Pokémon Company steps up production on a product that seemed scarce, your margin disappears. Remember the Charizard UPCs from October ‘22? Well, that’s how it goes.
-
Tied-up Capital. A bad purchase decision can leave you stuck for an entire year if you want to avoid selling at a loss.
-
Wild Competition. Every day, a new seller pops up on eBay or a new online store with dumping prices.
-
Reputation and Returns. One damaged shipment or inaccurate description and your reputation can suffer.
3.5. Best Practices to Keep the Gear Running
-
Daily Spreadsheet. Update your average purchase costs, real margins, and internal references for each product to track inventory rotation accurately.
-
Dynamic Pricing Policy. Adjust listings up and down depending on liquidity and season (Christmas peak, set releases).
-
Impeccable After-Sales Service. Corner protection, bubble mailers, and tracking: costs pennies, saves stars.
-
Hybrid Inventory. 80% fast (modern), 20% slow (blue-chip vintage) to balance cash flow and value.
-
Constant Networking. Get to know distributors, local stores, and high-level collectors; the best pieces never reach eBay or Cardmarket.
3.6. Where It Crosses with Other Profiles
-
Dealer–Investor. When you set aside a Trophy because you consider it undervalued and keep it for five years.
-
Dealer–Speculator. When you reserve 200 boxes of Obsidian Flames hoping for a launch flip.
-
Dealer–Collector. Danger: if you start holding inventory “because it looks nice,” you lower your margins and liquidity.
Conclusion
The dealer is the artery that keeps the blood circulating: buys in bulk, dissects the lot, and distributes cards to the world. Without them, collectors and investors would often fruitlessly search for that dream Charizard.
In the next stop, you’ll meet the Speculator, a specialist in flash trades and hype peaks. Ready to see what happens when the stopwatch—not the calendar—dictates your profits?
4. The Speculator: When the Stopwatch is Worth More than the Calendar
4.1. The Quick Play
Sunday, 06:59 AM. Prismatic Evolutions was just released a few days ago. You get a tweet: “Sunbreon PSA 10 ‘first to market’ sold for $5,432”.
07:02. You’ve already bought — with three bots and two Telegram profiles — five NM copies from various sellers.
Plan: receive, grade the PSA 10 candidates with express shipping, and dump everything on eBay before the market digests the bombshell. If everything goes well, in 2-3 weeks you’ll have recovered your capital and will have, as a friend of mine from school used to say, “handsome profits” ready to reinvest in the next play.
This is the heartbeat of the speculator: the short term is their entire universe.
4.2. What Drives the Speculator
-
Opportunity Window: Make money before the supply adjusts.
-
Light Capital: Only need a few hundred (not thousands) to turn each deal. With experience, large capital can bring big profits.
-
Absolute Speed: Buy at 8:00, list at 10:00 (yes, even before the product has arrived), sell at 14:00.
-
Aversion to Stock: If an item hasn’t moved in two weeks, it’s too heavy.
4.3. Distinctive Characteristics of the Speculator
| Trait | How It Translates to Pokémon TCG… |
|---|---|
| Real-time Alerts | Discord bots for restocks of high-liquidity sealed material. |
| Rotating Capital | €1,000 → €1,200 in 48 hours; reinvest instantly in the next flip. |
| Focus on Modern Product | Recent ETBs and Booster Boxes, recently hyped cards by streamers or in the middle of a pump & dump. |
| Instant Exit | Prefers to sell a Moonbreon BGS 9.5 with a 15% profit today rather than wait 6 months for a 30% (which may never come). |
4.4. Blind Spots and Risks
-
Failed Hype: Coming 1 or 2 days late to a trend can leave you stranded.
-
Accumulated Fees: PayPal + eBay + grading can eat up your profits if you miscalculate.
-
Emotional Overexposure: The temptation to “double down” after a successful flip can lead to poor decisions.
-
Reverse FOMO: You sell too early and see the card double in price two weeks later: guaranteed frustration.
4.5. Best Practices to Avoid Burnout
-
Rigorous Cost Spreadsheet: Include fees and commissions, shipping, and potential returns before hitting “buy”.
-
Stop-Loss Policy: If the price drops 10% below your purchase, liquidate and move on.
-
Diversify the Hype: Don’t put all your eggs in one basket; spread across 3-4 smaller opportunities.
-
Forced Rotation: If something hasn’t sold in 14-21 days, lower the price and free up cash.
-
Learn to Read The Pokémon Company’s Calendar: Stay updated on news and trends; know the dates for additional prints and set spoilers to anticipate.
4.6. Where It Crosses with Other Profiles
-
Speculator–Dealer. When you scalp exclusive playmats at events and sell them in your own online store.
-
Speculator–Investor. Keep ONE of each hype Booster Box just in case it becomes a blue-chip… but only if cash flow allows.
-
Speculator–Collector. Maximum danger: when you open boxes to “flip” and then fall in love with the cards; goodbye margin, hello personal FOMO.
Conclusion
The speculator lives in sprint mode: their goal is to catch the wave just before it crashes and jump to the next one without looking back.
When the market fills with product, the speculator buys the surplus and helps prevent stores from being stuck with dead stock; moreover, by reselling quickly, they set a reference price that shows how much people are willing to pay for something. However, when material becomes scarce, their urge to hoard only worsens the shortage of cards on the shelves.
The challenge—for them and for the rest of the ecosystem—is to distinguish when their buy-sell activity adds liquidity and when it becomes mere hoarding that chokes the hobby.
With all four profiles on the table, it’s time to see where they converge, where they clash, and how you can combine the best of each one without falling into their traps. Ready for the final mental duel? 
5. Overlaps and Hybrids: The Art of Mixing DNA Without Blowing Up Along the Way
Not everyone fits in a single box. Sometimes your game plan combines two (or more) mentalities, and, if managed well, that multiplies results and enjoyment. Other times, the mix becomes a Frankenstein that neither buys, nor sells, nor treasures to anyone’s satisfaction. Let’s look at four common hybrids, their advantages, and their hidden mines.
| Hybrid | How It Begins | The Best | Latent Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Collector-Investor | You start with nostalgia, discover the magic of Excel, and set a profitability plan. | You buy pieces you adore and filter for quality (top 10 %). Result: you enjoy while your assets grow. | Excessive attachment: when the time to sell arrives, the heart screams louder than the spreadsheet. |
| Investor-Dealer | You’re an investor with capital; you see that by taking on some rotation, you can increase cash for future premium purchases. | You sell some “non-core” inventory and generate cash flow without touching your trophy cards. | You end up tied to shipments, returns, and daily accounting: the “passive” profitability turns into a full-time job. |
| Dealer-Speculator | You have an online store and see a quick flip with newly launched booster boxes. | You leverage your distributor access: you get in cheaper and sell before casual resellers. | If you overstock and TPCi reprints heavily, you turn immediate profit into dead stock. |
| Collector-Dealer | You set up a store “to fund your collection” and keep what you fall in love with. | Privileged access to lots, conventions, distributor prices, and first opportunities. | Double-edged sword: each piece set aside is immobilized money; if you don’t set limits, your inventory turns into a personal showcase, and cash flow suffers. |
Keys to Make the Mix Work
-
Define percentages. Example: “70% inventory to sell / 30% to hold.” Write it down and stick to it.
-
Separate accounts (and emotions). A safe or folder for the “collectible” items, another for the “rotating” ones.
-
Review every six months. If your Collector-Investor is already 90% collector, it’s time to divest; if the Dealer-Speculator has accumulated stock for 90 days, liquidate and reinvest.
-
Communicate your role. When dealing with other profiles in the hobby, clarify whether you’re buying “for the store” or “for your personal collection.” Avoid misunderstandings (and overpricing).
Do you recognize yourself in any of these?
Take note of the advantages, set alarms for the risks, and keep the compass clear: mixing DNA is powerful… as long as you know which gene is in charge at each moment.
6. Impossible Hybrids (or Almost): Mixes That Usually End in Disaster
Some combinations sound tempting on paper, but in practice, they clash like oil and water. If you detect you’re getting close to one of these pairings, sound the alarms: the probability of frustration —and losses— increases exponentially.
| Anti-Hybrid | Why It Usually Tempts Us | What Ends Up Going Wrong | Warning Signs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dealer + Collector (the “Dealer-Hoarder”) | “I fund the store, and on the side, I keep what I love.” | You keep the best pieces and the rest never leave because they’re less liquid; your cash runs out and your space turns into a personal showcase. | >30% of inventory has been sitting for 6 months “because you like it.” |
| Investor + “Flip Addict” (investor chasing every hype) | “I make a couple of quick flips, and with that, I pay for my blue-chips.” | You end up chasing pumps, selling blue-chips to cover cash-flows, and breaking your 10-year plan. | You check your “favorites” on eBay more than your annual revaluation spreadsheet. |
| Omni-profile (you want to be all four at once) | “This way, I take advantage of all the benefits.” | Logistical stress, scattered focus, and contradictory decisions: you neither enjoy as a collector nor perform as a dealer. | There are boxes unlisted, an Excel spreadsheet not updated, and “forever cards”… all on the same table. |
How to Avoid Falling Into the Trap
-
Choose a dominant role and treat the others as complementary.
-
Set numerical limits (maximum stock “for me,” % of capital allocated to flips, etc.).
-
Quarterly audit: Is your time and profitability still aligned with the plan you laid out?
-
Conscious renunciation: You can’t maximize liquidity, nostalgia, and ROI at the same time.
With these three problematic mixes in mind —and knowing how to avoid them— you now have the full map. The only thing left is to discover which profile truly dominates you, and for that, comes a quick mini-test… 
7. Mini-test: Which Profile Dominates You?
Answer with the option that best reflects your usual reaction. Count how many A, B, C, and D you get.
| Question | A | B | C | D |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. A surprise restock of a highly sought-after modern set comes in. What do you do? | Buy two boxes to open and add to my binder. | Evaluate the price; buy only if I see long-term margin. | Request 60% of the stock for the store. | Sweep it with bots and list it right away. |
| 2. A card goes up 40% in two weeks. | Great, more value in my collection! | Note the increase; might sell if it hits +100%. | If I have stock, I’ll list it at market price. | Taking advantage of the wave, I try to buy cheap copies and resell today before it drops. |
| 3. You’re offered a mixed lot: 50% high-end vintage, 50% mass-produced modern. | I’m only interested in the vintage (or modern) part to keep. | Analyze ROI for each piece and might accept everything. | Can I break it up and rotate it quickly? | Take the modern pieces that can be flipped RIGHT NOW. |
| 4. Your display case is full and your budget is tight. | Make space: reorganize and enjoy. | Sell duplicates and reinvest in blue-chips. | Lower the price of slow-moving stock and buy more liquid products. | Open boxes Live to make a quick margin. |
| 5. You suffer an unexpected 20% loss. | “Bad luck, I keep collecting what I love.” | Adjust my plan, diversify, and continue. | Liquidate slow-moving inventory and protect cash flow. | Double down on another hot opportunity. |
Results
-
Mostly A – Collector. Heart first, Excel second.
-
Mostly B – Investor. Plan, discipline, and long-term horizon.
-
Mostly C – Dealer. Cash flow, margin, and rotation are your mantra.
-
Mostly D – Speculator. You live for the hype, and the clock is your heartbeat.
(Tie between two letters = hybrid profile; check section 5 to manage it without imploding).
Call to Action
What was your result? Let me know in the comments.
Share this test with that friend who always says “I’m not buying anymore today” and ends up bidding at 3 a.m.
I’ll be happy to read your feedback. Feel free to leave it, and don’t hesitate to check out my other articles, which you can find on my profile.
Leave a like if you enjoyed it, it helps others read it too. 
What a piece for an awesome collection like yours!
