Collection Bloat

As time goes by, our collections can become bloated. Goals are left incomplete or change entirely, leaving many cards/items in our collection that we feel ambivalent or disinterest toward. Other times, we find ourselves buying cards that were too good of a deal to pass up, but they end up fitting poorly within our overall vision.

Does your collection suffer from bloat? How do you manage this?

24 Likes

Yes, some bloat going on at the moment. Past few months I’ve been on the crossroads of consolidating or not. I’m currently content with selling extras but the collector in me will never forgive myself if sell my non-duplicates.

10 Likes

I’ve pretty much consolidated my collection down to a few categories:

  • Piplups (etc)
  • Radiant Collection sets
  • Playables
  • Sentimental cards

Anything beyond that goes into the trade binder to take to local shows and shops to hopefully trade for something in one of the categories above or to be sold. Non-playable bulk gets repurposed for art or proxy decks.

I feel like it’s really easy to want a little bit of everything when you start collecting (or come back after a break), but I’ve been strict with myself with my goals, and I don’t stray from them often. I genuinely can’t think of the last card I purchased that wasn’t for one of the above collections or for a deck.

I usually pick up one of each ETB art and that’s all I open for sealed as well, so I don’t have a ton of bloat in that regard either. Sometimes they’ll come out with a pin or eraser bundle with a few packs, and I do like those too, but I’m not really opening a ton of product at all.

It’s easy for collections like these to get out of control, so having a goal and sticking to it is super important for staying focused on what you really want for your cards.

8 Likes

As I get priced out of English 10s I concede and get the JP version, but now I am left with a en 9 and a jp 10. My bloat is not severe (maybe 6-7 slabs) but still makes up a good chunk of my collection, I will use it to trade into other cards I want.

5 Likes

I’m actually in the process of going through items I have no interest in, seeing if they’re worth grading, and then selling and putting the proceeds into something I actually want.

4 Likes

I continue to hoard the things i like.

22 Likes

For me not really. I have spent maybe too much time, creating sheets of what I want (mostly sets and subsets) and have been ONLY buying those cards over the years.

Setting up alerts and scripts scanning daily keeps me from doom scrolling sites like ebay - that focus and ignorance keeps me from buying a “good of a deal” card that doesnt fit inside my collection.

5 Likes

outside of mews, i just collect artworks i like, so there’s a bit of disarray but i dont mind it. i tend to lean toward cool exclusive promos but half my binder is just a bunch of random ARs that i think are cool

8 Likes

Basically my whole collection is bloat except my $tonkproof Fossil Hypnos. All shall be dealt with during c0ll3ct0rs West-German roadtrip of 2026. :psa: :hotdog: :bgs:

11 Likes

It’s a risk, but I like to think that I solved it by already planning what to buy.

For example, my binders are carefully planned and the amount of cards allowed is a fixed number: at some point I wanted a master set of Unseen Forces, Deoxys, Legend Maker and Crystal Guardians, but they just didn’t fit inside a 360 cards binder! So I forced myself to choose a favorite (LM) and then I only buy the cards I like the most from other sets.

I also have a list for graded cards that I really really want, and I try sticking to that. I allow a bit of room of course, but I tend to remind myself “you like vintage - no full arts - the majority of promos are better enjoyed in a binder ..” and so on!

6 Likes

I don’t buy anything if i don’t have a framework for it, early day random purchases are all sold, traded or in process of getting sold

The amount of frameworks i do have is a topic we do not talk about tho

9 Likes

I think my life would be 80% better if I got rid of all of my bloat cards (and stopped buying more), but then what would I flip through in my binders? And what would i spend money on once a week?

5 Likes

Totally get bloat, i usually slim down my collection at collectacons where i can sell all the stuff I accumulate and don’t want anymore. That or sell on eBay

2 Likes

I have a similar approach to @citriina, I pretty much only collect the following categories:

  • Slowpokes bros and kings
  • Eeveelutions (one binder of unique arts, not completionist)
  • Wooloos
  • Vintage / childhood cards

I also have one binder of misc modern cards and artworks I like from ripping ETBs and such. I suppose all the “bloat” goes into this binder

7 Likes

Yup, I’ve got some bloat.

I recently came to the realization, whats the point of keeping items that are currently in storage and not on display? My main collecting goals have always been sealed WOTC booster boxes, so why don’t I turn some of the extra stuff that I get little to no enjoyment from into a single item that I can display.

To help strategize, I recently cataloged and priced out each item in my collection, as well as determined which items I am okay with selling, which items I would sell to fund specific items, and which items are untouchable. That exercise really helped put into perspective just how much I have.

4 Likes

Once a year purge of undesirables

1 Like

It goes in the closet for a “forgot I had this” moment in the future

14 Likes

Sell

Sell

Sell

But my biggest bloat is from MTG lands. I buy hundreds of those each year to find just a few good ones. Sometimes, I hit grand slams, often the whole bulk lot is trash (Poor printing quality). So I have to recycle or toss them. Or if they’re nice cards, I give them to my LGS, or other players.

2 Likes

I suppose my collection does have some minor bloat, but I like to think that the cards I bought were the right card for what I wanted with the funds and interest I had at the time. They’re like a mini time-capsule for my collecting journey. At a minimum, I will photograph and document my cards, and then if they find their way to another home down the line, so be it.

7 Likes

I have some bloat, but for me it’s hard to differentiate what’s sentimental vs what can be consolidated. I haven’t opened too many packs since early SwSh and even then they were only for special occasions/when I had the money for it. As such, even pulls of Pokemon I don’t love are somewhat valuable to me. I also don’t live anywhere near places with card shows/LCSs so I can’t trade either. Kind of between a rock and a hard place lol…

2 Likes