There are a few other stressful difficulty walls in the pokemon games, but these two hold a very iconic place in the collective psyche. Also I couldn’t think of other truly difficult(non-post game) battles that were as tense as these. The other for me at least, is also gen 2, with jasmine, but that one didn’t catch on because you could ignore her gym until later I think.
Anyhow, what has you more fearful, Miltank, or Garchomp?
P.S. Why has pokemon failed to make a miltank card where it is using rollout in the art? That would be such a banger.
Whitney happened early on and there wasn’t too much stakes for losing, you could just try again after picking up a Machop. If you lost to Cynthia you were stuck spending another 20-30 minutes running through the entire elite four again, and you’d have to see the disgrace that is Flint so like, double punishment.
Pretty much what Maractus said. I would say Whitney is more difficult though; by the time you face Cynthia you’ve had the whole game to try and put together a team that can win. You have fewer tools available versus Whitney
I distinctly recall Cynthia from Pokémon Diamond thrashing me at least seven times in a row before getting lucky, my team underleveled, with a substance abuse problem to hyper potions and revives, and a carbon copy of whatever SuperSkarmory was running during his Diamond playthrough because I had no original team building thoughts at that age. Whitney I steamrolled when I got HGSS later on.
To this day, every time I hear the name “Whitney” I get flashbacks to that damn Miltank rolling over all of my Pokémon. Unfortunately the government doesn’t give enough support to us Goldenrod veterans…
If you struggled with Whitney, it may not have occurred to you to pick up a machop and karate chop your way to victory. Especially because rollout is a rock move and a lot of people started with cyndaquil
If you struggled with Cynthia, the scaling of dppt is bad and you were structurally failed by the game
I’m guessing many of y’all don’t play the game on set mode, I’ll take Whitney any day!
Also, strategies for Whitney: lower accuracy with sand attack, smokescreen, flash until she can’t hit you, rollout already starts at only 90% accuracy, paralysis with Mareep, sleep with Skiploom, Bellsprout etc., and Skiploom even gets Leech Seed, defense lowering moves on anything, Geodude, Onix, Quagsire to soak Rollout, Quagsire even gets accuracy dropping Mud Slap, the traded female Machop for super effective and unable to be attracted, Nidorino/Nidorina with double kick, also Croconaw just 1v1’s her. Quilava specifically gets Smokescreen and can be taught Dig to disrupt Rollout, Bayleef at this point has access to Poisonpowder and Reflect, which can help this fight too.
Also, A lucky kangaskhan in HGSS for double kick, and the benefit of levelling a Scrappy nature one for morty.
Whitney is straight forward: Stop The tank.
Choosing between these two, Cynthia’s battle was an excellent combination to create the tension: music, styling (in that generation, there was a strong awkwardness in general), and her team. Whitney you KNEW what was gonna be tough, but Cynthia, was difficult in different ways each time. Whitney was like fighting Lance: You knew when to stress.
Absolutely Whitney. But only because there was 6 or 7 years between when I played G/S and D/P. Fighting Cynthia as a 13 year old was easier than fighting Whitney as a 7 year old.
No one has mentioned it yet, but the timing of when they came out matters. Being young we just played for fun, and had more stress playing games when we struggled.
With that said I would say Whitney stressed me out more in past because we werent trained to optimize, but Cynthia was a lot more of a powerhouse overall, and the current stress nowadays is nonexistant for both strategy wise.
There are still some battles like May 2, that still stress me out as am adult though lol.