What Is Going On With Ebay Authenticity Guarantee?

I dont think the cards are worth enough to qualify for authentication, we all have opinions lol

i have 4-5 cards from first week in sept that have been authenticated but are in limbo and havent made it to the vault yet. but auth has been moving pretty quickly for me

1 Like

Less relevant to timing but my experience with the guarantee:

  • Bought a raw card described as NM for $350
  • Pictures showed the condition of the car fairly
  • Went to eBay
  • Took 10 days to process
  • Got an email while I was on business saying the card was actually LP
  • Authenticator took a picture of something shown in the original pictures
  • Seller offered 15% discount; his words, “not sure what eBay is on”
  • I was out of the country on business for 5 days
  • Discount expired
  • Card shipped back to seller, both parties disappointed

The delay on my end (5 days) was inexcusable and I understand there being an expiration date, but was bummed to miss out on the card and had no idea this was part of the program (condition check) when I found out the card was going to eBay for authenticity validation.

4 Likes

That makes sense, I only live like 25 minutes from PSA in Cali, although the mailbox I use is in San Diego county.

1 Like

dam thats sounds actually super convenient i would be there every week :rofl:

1 Like

I’ve sent 45 packages through eBay Authenticity Guarantee in the past few months. I’ve never had a graded card take longer than a few days to get through.

However, as a buyer, I have had an ungraded card sit for a few weeks. Maybe review of ungraded cards takes much longer (it should, in theory). But overall, most ungraded cards go through Authenticity Guarantee quickly, so it’s probably luck of the draw on which card gets held up.

1 Like

Wow right after saying that it gets authenticated. Looks like they just hate you Scott

I just had a card take 6-7 weeks to get through the Santa Ana authenticator, while multiple other cards ordered after the delayed one sailed right through… no rhyme or reason

3 Likes

I’ve had a few with significant delays when being sent to the vault. The authentication works fine and timely, but then the vault has taken about 3 times the normal length.

I assumed it was due to volume…
:woman_shrugging:

Update, my 9/22 authenticated card showed up in my mailbox today with another card that was authenticated on 9/24. However, they never updated or put in the tracking info and it still shows on eBay as not having shipped yet. Weird they would omit uploading that info onto eBay when shipping.

It was pretty funny too that the authenticity sleeve was completely split and open the whole length of one side. The card just slid out with the security seal intact, ha

1 Like

that sounds like someone messed up bad literally never seen that before :rofl:

I have two orders going out tomorrow that have to go through authentication (ungraded cards). I haven’t noticed a longer than normal dwell time lately there but I will pay more attention this time and see. I’m typically only buying/selling 1-2 cards a month that go through so my experience is fairly limited

I think anyone here who sleeves slabs has accidentally had it tear down one side before when fitting it in, but their sleeves are pretty loose so probably just a defective sleeve. I’m ready to be done with their authenticity process unless I specifically ask for it. 99% of the time it’s a step I don’t need given my experience and buying habits. At this point I think it’s more likely PSA would make a mistake in grading the card itself than I’d get scammed by a fake or altered slab or something. At least when buying PSA slabs. Can’t speak much for CGC or the other major players. That said, as the money goes up and the stakes get higher the fakes and scams always get better!

1 Like

i meant psa never uploaded tracking so what happens if the buyer files inr :rofl:

yeah ive seen those sleeves break at the side a couple times they really arent the greatest

Is this going to PSA vault? I sent out two orders for authentication on the 12th and 14th. The one on the 12th is going to vault and delayed, other on the 14th was already delivered to Japan

My order is not going to the PSA vault.

I actually called customer service and spoke with authenticity, a rep is going to follow up in a couple days. My specific order hasn’t even started the authentication process. Anecdotally my graded orders have been processing better, so maybe its something to do with raw cards. Either way I will update the thread when I hear back from the rep!

3 Likes

So weird hiccup I’m having with AG. I shipped multiple items to the Santa Ana office, on the same day. Two for the same buyer, one of those two hasn’t arrived like the rest did.

What on earth is happening here? Are they rerouting some packages to the Texas facility? Did PSA change the delivery? Why would it arrive on Friday (that’s like a trip around the world kind of timeline)? Anyone have this happen before?

Today I got a NJ location for eBay’s Authenticity Guarantee. First time that’s happened to me, all others have gone through Santa Ana in California. I would assume they chose this location because it’s closer to the buyer and they want the seller to take on the larger distance (shipping risk).

2 Likes

u shipped to the authenticator and it went from cali to tx without being delivered???

uhh that aint right at all

One weird thing I had was a $40 card went through authentication. Thought I was tripping. I was indeed, not tripping. It spent 4 total days at authenticator.

The total turn around from seller to me is 10-12 days on the couple other orders I had.
Since its a MTG card maybe they just don’t have anyone competent to be checking MTG cards. Plus PSA is already overstretched as a company as I’ve been told by others.

I’ve had bad authenticator experiences in the past.