I was wondering if anyone ever tried selling to troll and toad through their buylist and sending in a psa graded card? I’d imagine they would just give you the amount listed on their buylist.
Their buylist is their buylist you aren’t going to be offered more unless there are very specific circumstances
1 Like
They pay out the listed buylist price for psa cards. I’ve sent in some 8s before but I’m not sure if they look at the card inside the case for condition. I’m also not sure if they take psa 7 or lower but I hope this helps.
1 Like
They told me once when I asked them that they would pay cheaper for non NM graded cards (like how they offer HP and LP cards) but I’ve never actually tried sending them to see what they offer
1 Like
I did this with a PSA 8 Shining Raichu before. They were offering $240 and I was selling on ebay for $249.99 so I called them and asked if they wanted to take it in the case or out. The first person I talked to said I would have to break it out and then they would examine it. I reached out to a EVO representative there and he said to just send it in the case and they would gladly honor the buylist price.
5 Likes
Yeah I would think they would rather have stuff in the cases because more people would buy it if it was graded and if people didnt want it in the case they could always break it out.
1 Like