Hey all,
First of all, I want to thank everyone who has posted about that 18+k box that most are calling a counterfeit. I am in the process of auditing a box exactly like this, and through my own research, I have also become suspicious…and also a bit hopeful. Let me explain.
I am in the business, and had a client contact me about selling a box that he had picked up 6 years ago at an estate sale, along with a bunch of loose cards. He passes a lot of my “tests” when it comes to verifying his own trustworthiness (I’ve developed my own strategy for this over the years as a used-and-NOS-goods merchant), so needless to say, if his box is inauthentic, it will be news to him as well.
There are a number of these that have been floating around recently on ebay, and so that’s where my search started. These boxes all share a number of similar characteristics, and differ from other BSU boxes in exactly the same ways:
-A relatively loose, rectangle seal, with the Wizards logo slanted downwards rather than slanted upwards
-slightly different box art, most notable is the yellow background flavor on the front, which is a completely different pattern. Notice the darker, brown area in the lower left corner.
-Bottom has all the country codes, “Printed In USA”, and the MPN “WOC20153” rather than the other, more common “06033”.
As far as the boxes, they all appear to have identical construction to “normal” WOTC BSU boxes. One thing I have not been able to find is a great pic of the diagonal seam with the slight perforations on the bottom of the box- the one that I am auditing, I will see in person on Saturday. In any case, this was not just a single box that someone re-sealed and tried to pass off: There are at least 5 of these that I know of, including the one offered to me.
As a man of reason, I’m skeptical and have not made up my mind on them. However, I also am fairly familiar with the slap-dash way that Wizards printed Magic and Pokemon during their fledgling days, and the immense amount of packaging and box variations on nearly all of the sets released from the very beginning through the early 2000’s makes me wonder if all of these identical boxes may be another variant that simply looks different than the rest. At some point, someone will need to open one up. Remember, the seller that I am talking to has held onto this box for SIX years, and I do trust the guy at this point.
I will have more info and better photos on Saturday when I have the box in hand. I will do a peek test, I’ll grill the guy for all he’s worth, and see if I can either get him caught in a lie, or find out whether my feeling about him is correct- that he is telling the truth.
In any event, I find all of this fascinating. Here are some pics of the box I am going to see. imgur.com/a/Abvilh7