Thoughts on Mislabeled PSA Slabs Keeping Active Certs?

With all the recent attention around fake PSA slabs, it got me thinking about some of the mislabeled slabs that I come across more often than I’d like. I would think there would be additional scrutiny during an active listing or recent sales. It makes me wonder how often sellers know and still list them anyway because there can be a meaningful value difference.

I watch Stamp Rally listings pretty often and the most obvious examples to me are the Stamp Rally Eevee and Meowth (Stamp Rally versions are non-holo while the WotC promo is holo). This has always made me more hesitant with niche cards like these, or a card like the GOTTA Mew (which is much harder to tell apart from scans, and I’ve also seen labeled incorrectly). These obviously aren’t six figure examples, but still a good chunk of change for some.

Curious what others think of this? What other cards seem to get mislabeled often enough that you need to pay extra attention to when buying? This potentially hurts uneducated buyers and also throws off the true pop of rarer cards. I’m sure PSA isn’t the only grading company making these mistakes, but they get the most volume, so it stands out more. I feel like there should be an easy reporting system for clear mislabels.

Here are some examples that still show active certs, the first one being an active listing:


53745265


107216761


160426265


93333386


122085160


122085159

I did find a recent example where the cert name appears corrected on PSA’s site, so hopefully that means the label was corrected too (26358110).


26358110

1 Like

TMB and Trainer Mag Bilingual Exeggutor. Seems at least a couple people way overpay each year who don’t know to check the tie.

3 Likes

You see this with the WHF neo genesis starter trio cards and the gold star champion road neo genesis trio as well. Both a fairly niche and easily confused among collectors.

1 Like

There are so many wrong labels out there, so I don’t think there is much to do about it except for paying attention and being informed when you buy cards.

However, many wrong labels are mostly fairly harmeless such as forgetting a “1st edition” or having the wrong year. Sometimes you can even get a deal if the seller does not know that the mislabeled variant is more valuable (e.g., 1999-2000 base or no-rarity). Other examples are just odd. For instance, look at this “Base set Magneton” that is being auctioned:

1 Like

Buy the card not the label. Sorry not sorry - if someone spends a lot of extra money on the JR Stamp Rally Eevee label on an obviously holo card, maybe they should stick to $5 singles in their early collection journey

1 Like

I guess I was more thinking along the lines of leaving active certs would seemingly encourage sellers with bad intentions to keep mislabeling, especially with the immediate buybacks that get offered. Obviously if a buyer cant tell the difference between a holo and non holo card, that’s their own problem, but there are cards that are harder to differentiate with a scan. I think it looks bad all around that these obvious errors even get through