QotD: If you had to sell off all but 6 cards now, what would you keep?

Welcome to the Question of the DDK!

The Question of the DDK is a way to facilitate community disc- Oh, I can’t use that line or it will incur the wrath of an angry Ampharos.

With the market being insanely hot right now, many longtime collectors have decided to sell off large portions of their collections. It got me thinking, if you hypothetically had to sell off everything except for 6 cards now, which ones would you keep?

I chose 6 as that’s the number of Pokémon a trainer can carry at any time in both the video games and anime and felt this would be a fun topic to get people to think about which cards are the most important to them. These may not necessarily be the most expensive cards one owns, but perhaps something from your childhood, a card tied to a fond memory or one with rich history behind its creation.

I’ll start us off:

image
image
image
image
image
image

English and Japanese are the two language I collect so I wanted to have an even mix of both.

Team Rocket was my favorite set growing up, so I would want to keep a card to remember a piece of that. I picked Dark Charizard as it was the chase of the set and I still remember being wowed by the “edgy” depiction of it when I saw it on the playground in elementary school.

Neo Discovery Espeon was the first graded card I ever purchased, so I treat it as my “starter”. It’s one of Nishida’s best artworks and my favorite Eeveelution, so I could never part with it.

Skyridge became my favorite set of all time after I got back into collecting as an adult and the Crystal Celebi was a huge milestone for me to acquire. It’s my favorite depiction of this mythical and symbolizes the e-series that I’ve come to love collecting.

The 7000 points PLAY Mew ex is here for a variety of reasons. I kept it to remember the ex era that I’ve been collecting, the artwork is incredibly nostalgic, harkening back to the final stage in Pokémon Snap, and it’s a nifty prize card.

Fan Club Eevee was a card that I had been chasing for years. The history behind it is really cool, it’s genuinely a decently rare card, and the background artwork with Vaporeon, Flareon and Jolteon just brings back memories of first obtaining Eevee from the roof of Celadon city and having to make the decision of what to evolve into.

Finally, CoroCoro Illusion’s Zoroark is here because I would want to keep at least one card where only a few hundred copies exist period. Ho-oh is also my all-time favorite Pokémon and I love the illustration because it captures a child’s imagination in the purest form, which is how I felt when I saw the golden phoenix at the end of the anime’s first episode.

Looking forward to seeing what other members would choose as their final team of six!

14 Likes

So confused when i saw the title.

If i had to sell all my loose cards except 6, I would have to keep those that i enjoy looking at the most.

-Ancient mew for its history and personal nostalgia,
-Carddass mew because i love the holo on it and mew looks very cute,
-Memo card because i love the back side art on them,
-Playtest card because i sourced it before all controversy and believe it to be real and a unique part of tcg history,
-Mewtube because it was the first card i pulled when getting back into pokemon
-The last one would probably Snorlax tg10 due to personal sentimental reasons.

Thanks for the thought experiment. Please dont ask me to do this for my decks.

7 Likes

I’d choose cards that would be difficult or impossible to replace, either due to rarity or sentimental value. I’m also going to not include signed cards.

There’s a bunch of difficult to find Slowpokes that I’d need to hold onto to actually restart the collection, but these are four of my favorites with good stories. Plus my two favorite childhood cards.

  • Korean coloring book promo: The whole saga was so much fun from start to finish and this card means a lot to me. If I had to pick one card to sum up my entire collection, it would be this one. Shout out @dylancollectsglaceon and @goonhoon team 121/s-p forever
  • Dutch unlimited fossil Slowpoke: This set is very rare and I really still can’t believe I got this one in such good condition. I spent a long time diving into the world of Dutch Pokemon cards and hunted very intensely for it. I made some friends in The Netherlands along the way :slight_smile: I have the Slowbro too, but since we’re limited here, I’d keep the Slowpoke as a memory of both
  • Thai gym promo Slowpoke: Some SM-era Thai gym promos are weirdly hard to find and I was very stuck on this one, until @dylancollectsglaceon spotted it in a Thai facebook group. Him DM’ing me asking me if I’m “locked in” really cements this card as one of my favorite memories. Dylan, I just realized you’re featured in two of my six cards :laughing:
  • Spanish Neo Genesis 1ed Slowking: This is another one of those weirdly rare sets. I made connections with a bunch of Spanish collectors looking for this one so there’s good memories attached. I love this artwork and it’s in great condition too, so I’d keep this one as my WOTC holo of choice.
  • Skyridge umbreon from my childhood collection: I adore this artwork and have loved the Eeveelutions since I was a kid, so I definitely want to keep this one. It’s between this and my Aquapolis Espeon, but since we can only keep six, I think this would serve as a memory of both.
  • Legend maker Arcanine from my childhood collection: The version of this card I have from childhood is completely bent in half, but I absolutely love it. It also has a cool swirl. I think about getting it graded sometimes (it’d probably get a 1 or a 2)

9 Likes

I also choose to keep ddk’s cards

10 Likes

Sir, that is illegal

5 Likes

It’s okay, we can share. I truly don’t mind

6 Likes

My favorite Swampert and Charizard arts are a no brainer. I have deep attachment to the Aggron EX I pulled with my friend as a kid, the Mewtwo and Umbreon are among my favorite of the EX. The Marill is an odd one. I don’t know why, I just vividly remember loving this card when I was like…4.

13 Likes

Aww thanks! :blush:
So glad I could help with TWO slowpokes!! :smile:

I’ll make a post here later!

2 Likes

From top left clockwise -

My favourite card of all time of my favourite Pokémon.
My favourite art of another of my favourite Pokémon.
Possibly the best art in the history of the TCG, so far ahead of its time to tell a story like that.
Glorious, unique art that really showed where Pokémon cards could go in the future, the Tag Team alts got me back into serious collecting in 2019.
Old back JP exclusive with a decent amount of history.
This card makes me hate myself but I would still keep it.

6 Likes






  • Gyarados VMAX 207: To be very honest, I started my collection when I saw Rainbow Pikachu from Vivid Voltage. I love anything rainbow for personal reasons, and Gyarados is my second favorite Pokémon ever. I like this one from Evolving Skies better than the Crimson Invasion counterpart because it looks closer to the Gyarados figurine my twin bought me. This is also the first card and first graded card in my collection.
  • Magikarp 080: Kanda’s Giratina SIR and Magneton IR made me appreciate Pokémon cards more. I grew up collecting Yu-Gi-Oh cards, so I didn’t know much about Pokémon. Good thing Kanda also illustrated Magikarp. This is my second card and second graded card. I got this one in Japanese because I wanted to have cards in the two main languages.
  • Gyarados GX 112: After holding it in my hand, I think the texture on GX cards is better than the VMAX. Same reason as before, I like rainbow things. Also, because I only have two stands for now, this card accompanies the other Gyarados on my home office table, while I keep the Magikarp in the box until the other stand arrives.
  • Mudkip 045: My favorite Mudkip card artwork. I love blue, and the shades of blue in the background with the thick black outline around Mudkip look really nice. I also love the silver border, so I chose this card in Indonesian.
  • Mudkip 56: My second favorite Mudkip artwork really depends on the day. But this card’s yellow background takes a special place in my heart because yellow is my mom’s favorite color. I associate anything yellow with her. I chose this one in German to represent my German collection too.
  • Alolan Vulpix 023: One of the gifts from my twin sibling. They love Komiya, and Alolan Vulpix was my go-to Pokémon when I played Pokémon Unite a few years ago. That was a nice time when I played with some old friends, and those happy memories are attached to this cute little Pokémon. Also, the Indonesian Alolan Vulpix Pokédex entry (which is different from the English counterpart) is really sweet.

Cheers,
Adhi

7 Likes

PSA 8 4th print zard

PSA 4 4th print zard ( my first card I graded myself)

PSA 8 4th print blastosie

PSA 7 Shadowless charizard

PSA 9 Shadowless alakazam

PSA 9 fan club eeve

2 Likes

Corocoro mew

Goldstar mew jp

Ancient mew I corrected

Ancient mew Nintendo error

Chinese exclusive promo mew

Orbit mew (same as yours op!)

3 Likes

i love this approach to thinking about a collection!! i had a fun time narrowing it down :slight_smile: i decided to choose three cards that i collected as a child and three i’ve collected since coming back to pokemon cards.

childhood card #1 = 1999-2000 fossil zapdos, it has a lovely swirl in it’s grasp, i always loved the sparkle :slight_smile: i had no concept of it being strange to have a fossil card with the cosmos holo, i got it in a trade with another child who was probably also unaware and just assumed it was normal.

childhood card #2 = base set ued venusaur. this was the first holo card i ever had and i carried it with me everywhere, i loved flowers and frogs and the fact that it had 100 HP lol.

childhood card #3 = uf lugia ex, the first and only card i pulled as a child that had a sparkly border. and an attack that does 200 damage?? how can you beat that.

adulthood card #1 = expedition butterfree, i recieved this in a trade with @bbobrob which makes it v special!! i always loved butterfree and the way the holo ghosts through the wings/body (which i can’t seem to photograph but i’m convinced it’s there) is so soft and pretty.

adulthood card #2 = uf quagsire rh (upside down holo layer), the first (and only, so far) card i ever got from a slab, and my favorite special interest card. i like errors a lot and scour for quags regularly so when this came up i had to do it :slight_smile:

adulthood card #3 = aquapolis quagsire rh, my favorite card of my favorite pokemon, i adore e-series and the reverse holos especially, and the art feels so energetic and detailed :blue_heart:

7 Likes

easy one for me. already posted the six cards in another thread:

3 Likes

6 Likes

Phenomenal Zapdos Pick. Thank you.

1 Like

This was very hard to do but at the end of the day it is all childhood based cards of mine that would survive. In no particular order:

Torterra Lv. X. I have a vivid memory of opening my very first Diamond and Pearl pack and pulling this from a single blister. Even better that Torterra was my favorite of the starters.

My very first Aggron card. I remember being frustrated about not having a card of my favorite Pokemon, so my family ended up buying one for me off of eBay. We looked through some of the different cards listed and I chose this one. I paid them $5 for it if I remember correctly. It was either my mom or grandpa that helped me with using their eBay account.

My first Rayquaza card as well! From the Jetstream theme deck. Still have the empty theme deck box as well as the paper playmat and coin. This card has seen a lot of love.

I’d say this is my favorite ex pull as a kid, Scyther ex from Ruby & Sapphire. Just a really cool, nostalgic card for me.

Reverse holo Dark Tyranitar from EX Team Rocket Returns. I remember pulling this card twice in one pack, the reverse slot was this, and the rare spot was the non-holo version. I remember trading away the non-holo version, and keeping this one tucked away ever since.

Technically not a card from my childhood, my childhood copy is the non-holo version, but I’ve been enamoured with the card since I ever saw it! And I’d just have to keep the holo version cause it is just so pretty.

Runner-Up:

Just a really gorgeous card that I pulled two of when I was a kid. I had to still include it cause I was really torn on the last one to include. I’m still thinking if I would take this or the Lanturn and so I’ll just leave this in runner-up status. The rainbow effect in this card is so cool in person. I also definitely used my extra as trade bait back in the day, but for what? I don’t remember.

8 Likes