1st Ed Base Zard 8.5. Perfectly happy with it and have been getting offers exactly halfway between last sold on psa 8 and 9. Just comes down to personal preference just like anything else.
Aw man that one straight from the pack got an 8.5?? Or is this a different one?
1 Like
The Charizard pull was eventually graded a BGS 9.
The 8.5 is a different one.
1 Like
Call me crazy but actually love the .5 grades. Something about them feel unique and I actively pursue PSA 1.5’s! If you got one let me know 
2 Likes
a .5 grade is going to be valuable/desirable based on the card and the buyer who wants it. Some people will like it and some people won’t like it