I think a more interesting decision is between being an 80 year old billionaire or being 20 years old and broke. Most of us here are still in a phase of our life where we have a lot of time hopefully ahead of us and so it’s an easy decision to take the money.
Time > money every time. People always figure out that too late

10-20 years as Richard Branson or who knows how long in a tent on skid row. At the extremes it becomes interesting.
I would have gone back to childhood until I saw the option without memories
Nah if I want to relive, correct something or experience it I need to have memories. Just playing the same play again without remembering doesn’t seem well.
I will take the $1M and try to give a better childhood some via donations for children who are losing it and with remaining I try to build my life better..![]()
I’m in a good spot. I loved my childhood too. Maybe I would’ve made different decisions to set me on the wrong course, so I’ll take the moolah now
I would take the $1M without a second thought.
An ascended point of view. If you would go backl to do it again, when you get to this point, you would again, go back again. If nothing changes, you’re essentially saying, I don’t want to move past this point. Merely repeating your life over and over up until this point… Why?
I have a wife and kid. I’m not swapping them for childhood nostalgia even though I dearly miss people.
I would give just about anything to warn my mum about her cancer in 2023 and it’s fun to think about buying shares/bitcoin/pokemon cards or whatever.
I even joke about using a time machine to tell the defender to stand slightly to his left to stop my team losing the Scottish cup final.
But it would certainly prove impossible to mirror the sequence of events to make my family happen again so current timeline for me.
Reliving it as a spectator/being unaware of what happens later would be pointless. You could be doing that now over and over and be unaware.
Stop spying on me ![]()
Even if I could keep my memories and live life again and become a trillionaire I still wouldn’t leave my kids. Easy decision for the $1m
I would love to go back and relive my childhood. I am lucky that I had a good one that I have fond memories of. With that said, however, I would not give up the time I have spent and will spend with my child for anything. This question gives me the impression that essentially it is a time loop that at this point will always restart and I want to see my child grow up. (I also don’t want to live through COVID lockdown again lol)
I’m curious a poll for everyone here:
- You take all knowledge with you
- You leave all knowledge behind
It seems to me that what while I assume, the choice is between benefiting from lessons learned or hoping things might be different on a second run-through, is not the assumption everyone makes. ![]()
I generally agree that memory is pretty important here.
I think the only situation when it might be ok without memory is if it’s not just a repeat of the past. If there’s some kind of change you are allowed to make to the original timeline, then going back in time without memory might be better to get an authentic experience.
Even then, I think you’d want your memory restored at some point so that you can fully appreciate the experience.
But if the idea is to repeat the same timeline you already experienced, then yeah it’s pointless without memory to anchor and contextualize everything during the experience.
I had a great childhood, and I would love to go back. But if that means I’ll be stuck back there and I have to relive my whole life again without any memories from the present, then it’s not worth it. If it’s only for a couple of days then sure, but I don’t want to go through everything again.
Also, as much as I would love to see my late Dad and Grandma again, they would think I’m stupid for not taking the $1M. So yeah, I’ll be taking the money lol!
There are a lot of childhood moments I would enjoy revisiting, and a lot I wouldn’t. You couldn’t pay me to slog through the first 12 years of school again.
I wouldn’t give up my current life even for the version where I get to exploit my knowledge to become ultra wealthy, but without that it’s not even a decision. +$1M please