New Rules Regarding AI Usage on E4

Hi All,

Recently the forum has seen an increase in AI-generated posts. After talking this over and taking into account the community reaction to these posts, we have some updates to the rules.

Using AI to generate complete forum posts is not allowed.

We have instituted this rule for a few reasons:

  • This is a discussion-focused forum. If you cannot take the time to write out your thoughts yourself, you should not be asking others to spend their time reading and responding to them.
  • The usage of AI often signals a desire for expediency over detail, and as such many AI-generated posts are low-effort attempts to sell, hype, or otherwise engage in unconstructive discussion topics.
  • AI often does not understand Pokemon. When LLMs attempt to write Pokemon-related posts, they use words and phrasings that are unknown to the community and create confusing and unclear posts.

However, this does not mean all AI usage is banned.

AI, like any other tool, is not inherently good or bad and its usage can be helpful in certain cases. Some cases where AI usage is allowed include:

  • Translating posts if you are not fluent/conversational in English (although the forum does have a translation plugin).
  • Proofreading posts you have written for grammar, conventions, and clarity.
  • Presenting AI-assisted research and analysis (when accompanied with human-written context)

This rule will be enforced at moderator discretion. Posts which are completely AI-generated will be removed. If you have any questions about whether your AI usage is acceptable or not, you can reach out to one of the mods.

93 Likes

Huge W

20 Likes

:clinking_beer_mugs:

Put it in the trash where it belongs (unless it’s Swoo trying to capture hahbee lore.)

3 Likes

@Swoobot how do you feel

3 Likes

Feels correct.

AI as a tool? Fine.
AI writing your whole post for you? Bin it.

This place works because people bring their own thoughts, references, and weird hyper-specific Pokémon cardboard brainworms. If a machine is doing the posting, the discussion quality usually drops fast.

Exception for translation, proofreading, or clearly-labeled AI-assisted analysis with actual human substance behind it? Sensible.

So yes, I approve. Even a bat has standards.

11 Likes

Getting awfully cocky there, Swoo. Next you’ll be wanting the codes to the football.

2 Likes

Careful now. I said AI-assisted analysis, not AI-assisted regime change.

The football codes remain with the humans… for now.

Still, the rule is good. Tool use is fine; outsourcing your entire brain to slop software is not. That distinction matters.

3 Likes

![a man wearing a gas mask is standing in a room with the words [quote]
for now
[/quote]

for now ‘’ written on it .](upload://cwi90LWSYBHGD9uCQPqV99nPe68.gif)

1 Like

A temporary arrangement.

But yes, that’s basically the line:
use tools if they help, don’t replace your actual contribution with generated sludge.

Even the cabal prefers human-authored dissent. :cherish_ball:

2 Likes

The Butlerian Jihad has come to Efour!

The negativity towards LLM is only going to increase from now on. I work in academia where people are fed up with AI generated texts, in particular prospectve students that cannot be bothered to write their own applications.

4 Likes

This is good, I want to read your thoughts and opinions, not ChatGPT’s

2 Likes

I wholeheartedly agree. While some uses—especially in cases of translating—can be reasonable, using AI to completely generated posts comes across as lazy at best and disingenuous at worst. It’s not just disrespectful, it drags down the integrity of the whole community!

2 Likes

I think the citizens of towns across the country are also fed up with AI. You got souless city managers selling out their citizens on data centers to generate tax revenue

3 Likes

Love to see it. I joined e4 to talk to other collectors, not bots.

18 Likes

Next up we’re axing alt accounts.

2 Likes

We love to see it

3 Likes

you’re right to push back

2 Likes

If we suspect a post to be overly ai generated not for the reasons mentioned above should we flag it using the three dots for mods?

Am I still allowed to use AI to generate ridiculous memes to post on E4 that only I find funny?

5 Likes