How much should TPC/TPCi actually be printing?

Recently there was a post on the r/pokemontcg subreddit complaining about the state of the hobby and the lack of product available in Canada compared to the US. In the comments, but also the general sentiment I’ve read for awhile, is that this is also not unique to Canada, but is the norm everywhere else too; Europe, Australia, South East Asia etc.

TPC/i printed between 9.1-11.9b cards in the last 5 years and the fact that the last 2 are nowhere near the 11.9b peak suggests that capacity has been maxed out - after all, the facilities also print other TCGs which are also booming.

They are due to open a larger, and perhaps exclusive facility in 2028, but how much more cards do they really or should they really be printing?

Whilst all these people are unable to get product, enough product or product at retail prices, the singles’ prices for all these cards continue to slide (well, it took awhile but it’s here). The sealed prices for booster boxes for 2026 sets have also been inching closer to MSRP on TCGPlayer which is the proxy for US market prices even if it is not realized elsewhere.

It brings to mind the finding that if everyone on Earth were to consume as much as the average American, we would need 5 Earths. I understand that the distribution of supply is not equal or even proportionate, but should TPC/i print to demand?

The expected value of a booster box might be the worse it’s ever been. Even excluding the billions of bulk cards - at min. 91% of cards printed, there is not enough demand for 90% of the individual secret rare cards to be worth more than the pack. There is oversupply even with the amount of sealed hoarders running amok.

There will never be enough supply to cater for degenerate gamblers or even the casual collector.

A better solution rather than ‘print more’ would be to raise pull rates either directly or reducing the amount of bulk that is printed (ENG packs going from 10 cards to 5 like JP) which in turn would increase the amount of packs and hits being distributed.

They’re earning shit loads of money and don’t care that much

1 Like

Well as the owners of the IP it’s really up to them how much they print. All their decisions seem pretty logical to me when you look at it from a long term business perspective. Basically they have a few variables they control such as print run, set size and chase pull rate, and they can tune things up and down over time as interest in the hobby from casual consumers waxes and wanes.

Over the last two years they’ve been trying to delicately balance maintaining speculator interest while retaining casual fans, in other words, selling as much to as many people as possible, and I think they’ve mostly done a good job. Since speculator interest in modern has starter to wear a little over the last six months I would expect a tightening of the print runs or more likely larger sets in the 2nd half of 2027 going into 2028.

As a general rule pre orders going back to being what you use to gauge how much to make would solve a lot of the issues. A pre order shouldn’t “sell out” or be unavailable, because the company should be producing to initial demand. Anybody who wants a pre purchase product should be able to get one. Maybe you’re not getting it exactly on release day, fine. The Pokémon company / TPCi is one of the largest media brands in the history of the world. They could figure this out if they wanted to.

1 Like

As I mentioned above, I think it’s a US-centric view that they have supplied enough since the feedback from everywhere else (TPCi supplied not TPC) is that they have not. At the same time, they themselves are constructing/expanding a new facility to increase production which is a massive investment if they are unsure about demand.

But my somewhat contradictory point is that, I’m not sure it’s a good idea. I suppose strike while the iron is hot even though it would be 4/5 years after the Pocket/Surging Sparks boom.

Maybe I’m just conflicted because it just seems so wasteful and degenerate.

One box isn’t enough to satiate these people but at the same time, you’re not getting much out of only one box. But with the excess supply of all these ultramodern cards that don’t even move that fast, it just seems like what’s the point of printing more when the singles don’t even sell?

Well the good thing about it for PCI is that they own MPG which sort of operates as a separate entity. MPG can print more than Pokemon cards if demand falls.

True but given a choice, how many boxes do you think people would pre-order?

I know Japan has sort of done it before, but their order limit is 1. Even as a player, you can’t pull a playset of what you need with only 1 box.

At the same time, despite these pre-orders being lottery based and not even having a 100% fulfilment, there are seemingly hundreds of thousands or millions of boxes exiting Japan on top of the massive amounts that the local stores get.

It’s like a false market/supply shortage.

Also as a thought experiment using the 11.9b record print run:

Assuming that they are all English and the only product is booster boxes of 4 sets/year

There would be 7.5m booster boxes per set.

Using PokeRev’s 3.3m subscribers to represent the whole market

It would be 2.2 boxes per person.

The reality of course is that there are 13 languages, a myriad of products, nonsense like energy bricks, special sets and there’s probably more than 3.3m people in the hobby (though obviously not everyone is interested in opening packs). Also we are down nearly 2b from the peak print run.

So they cannot offer unlimited pre-orders because it would be impossible to fulfil them. At the same time, do we really need more cards when most ultramodern singles are bulk priced?

Obviously as a company, they will want to maximize profit and there’s still that massive unfulfilled demand they can tap into instead of leaving it for distributors, retailers and scalpers to take advantage of. It just seems like the depth of interest in the final product - the cards themselves - is pretty shallow.

That is true, though I feel like the whole TCG market sort of rises and falls together.

Or perhaps it’s more like the giants (MTG, Pokemon) have helped the rest and if they falter, I don’t think that the demand will shift to other properties.

Anecdotally where I live in Australia, Kmart is fully stocked with packs of Chaos Rising and Pitch Black at fair prices and has been stocked ever since Perfect Order. Modern single chase cards such as illustration rares and special illustration rares have higher prices on the secondary market than I can justify paying for them, so I don’t really think they’re cheap.

Thanks for the insight. Does Australia have their own market price reference?

In Malaysia, it’s basically the US market price now for singles but packs are all marked up.

And although there seems to be card shows every weekend for the last year that are well attended, I don’t know how much is actually selling since I see the same stuff at most vendors.

Print less junk.

No energy plus 2 less cards per pack = 30% increase in capacity

3 Likes

In America I would say they haven’t printed enough still. Finding product on shelves is still very much the exception and not the norm.

Personally I’d be down with them printing no energies in packs and far fewer commons in packs. Just toss the energies in ETBs/whatever the equivalent of a starter deck is today and call it there.

The big problem is everyone needs more because of how fucked the rarities are right now. Any given gold star was roughly 1 every 216 packs. Any given SIR in Prismatic Evolutions is 1 in close to 1500 packs, or 1 in 500 for your “normal” sets.

4 Likes

The pack/set makeup and pull rates are the real issues. Do we really need some 200+ cards, 90% of which are bulk, every 3 months? Do we really need chase cards that are 1/xxx+ packs?

Anyways, fewer cards per pack and or fewer cards per set can have a big impact on supply. I think thats whats happened the last year or so. Fewer cards per set (in theory) means you can print a lot more when all is said and done. A simplification, but it seems pretty reasonable to me

2 Likes