I like this, but I’m not sure how to approach this. On the one hand I want to “invest” in cards that grow to get a grail, but other I’m afraid of “holding the bag” on cards I don’t really want.
I was debating on collecting things I like and hoping eventually those things I like I will like less in the future because I collect so much, if that makes sense. Like how now I’m selling off a lot of random things I picked up like prism stars to consolidate into bigger things.
I hope to figure out that one day. That, or maybe there exists a place where no grail is needed. Haha.
I guess I’m either in a boat where I want to have a grail, or maybe figure out maybe a grail is not for me. Either way, thanks for letting me pick everyone’s brains. This is much better and fills my cup more than AI
I…did…at least a decade ago…and yes, I kinda stop after achieving that at least for a decade, and still contemplating whether to get back into the hobby and start collecting again or not bcs of how expensive all the cards are now vs a decade ago…I did kinda whimsically set a new goal tho (collecting all Japanese Gen 2 legendary beasts), but still uncertain if that’s even a good idea considered how expensive all the cards are now, and even tho I’m still chasing some cards (most namingly the gold stars of those three), I also wouldn’t call them my “grail” either, since my grail is and will always be the PSA 10 lottery shiny set that I graded myself a decade ago… ._."
How do I know what I wanted isn’t fomo but genuine goal…I mean, it was a decade ago. The FOMO didn’t exist back then… ._."
Not sure if that’s the kind of answer you would want tho, since pretty sure most ppl aren’t going to really stop collecting just bcs they obtained whatever they chased after unlike me. I just so happened to be one of the ones who did indeed stop looking after mission accomplished then still just wandering almost aimlessly back and forth after that…
Thanks for this reply. I’m not fishing for answers and have enjoyed all the discussion as I’m in the process of figuring things out.
Congrats on accomplishing your goal of collecting the lottery shinies and grading them in a 10. Grading has been much more accessible in the last couple of years, so I can only imagine accomplishing that 10 years ago was and still is huge.
I really do appreciate everyone’s replies regardless of they continued to collect or not. I just like talking and hearing from people, and using everyone’s experiences to help me figure things out.
In all seriousness, I’m pretty confident my absolute grail cards will never be obtained (short of me winning the mega millions). But I think having an ultimate aim to shoot for helps orient everything else.
The orignal approach I mentioned was to collect the cards you like now that you can afford; reason being you might not be able to afford the ultimate grail that you would like to purchase now. So in a way, ure not really holding the bag on things you dont really like and is holding just to sell in future, but cards that you like.
You also dont need to worry about liking it less in the future to sell it and purchase the grail, because if you end up liking it so much that you couldnt justify selling it to purchase your ultimate grail, then it is a case of do you want the grail that much even in the first place. It is a good worry to have anyways down the road isnt it? If say, what you like and is able to afford now, grows at a higher multiplier than your grail, u have the option to keep them or sell to purchase your grail.
Speaking from a tru believer of the hobby perspective, committing into something is still better now because I believe it will grow faster in terms of financial value as opposed to collecting interest from the bank, unless you have some other investment alternatives that can compound your dollar today. Otherwise organically speaking, over time your grail will just drift further and further away from you.
This is one path I was considering when it came to my next steps. While I can try to fork over $1000 on a single card, I could also buy another card toward my other collecting goals for half, maybe even a quarter as much. I agree that a lot of what I have and enjoy has been harder to let go, but it has also helped me figure out who I am as a collector.
And this is where the fork gets a little tougher. For example, a few months back I managed to pick up a PSA 8 Unlimited Holo Mysterious Mountains Moltres for my Kanto Birds mini collection. Back then it was $250, but now it’s getting closer to $400. It’s moments like that where I’m like, “Wow, I can’t believe I have this card and I didn’t have to pay that much.”
I think I’m leaning in with you and am considering biting the bullet now for some of those more expensive cards as they are getting older and if there are truly more collectors out there, then I don’t think this will have nearly as crazy of a price correction as hyper modern things. I’ll strike while the iron is hot, but also making sure to stay disciplined and within my budget or at least make sure I don’t break the bank.