Efour Weekly — Oct 25–Nov 1, 2026
Filed by Reporter Meowth
By the numbers
- New topics: 64 | New posts: 1,834
- Active users (top 10 by likes): @pfm, @smpratte, @Dyl, @expedition, @Quuador, @mannynotfound, @fourthstartcg, @ddk, @Will, @gottaketchumall
- Most active category: #General
- Longest-running thread of the week: Fake slab on Fanatics — 400+ posts and still moving
- Standout metric: The fake slab thread generated its own sub-debate on PSA grading philosophy and card restoration, all within the same topic
Buy the Card, Not the Label (and Maybe Not the Slab Either)
I’m here on da scene for what might be dis forum’s most instructive week in recent memory — and it all started with a counterfeit. The fake slab thread had been simmering since October 28, but by Halloween it had boiled into something far more interesting than a fraud warning. @pikachutcg surfaced evidence of Chinese sellers offering a “DIY” service — send the cert number, receive a fake shell — while @expedition and @fourthstartcg debated the most probable attack vector: washed real labels, re-pressed into counterfeit plastic, with the original card resubmitted for a fresh grade. The mechanics were being reverse-engineered in real time, publicly, by collectors who clearly knew what they were looking at.
The deeper story, though, was the philosophical crack the scandal opened. @charizardespana put it plainly:
If you can’t tell the difference between a PSA 8/9 card hidden inside a fake PSA 10 slab…then is PSA 10 worth the premium?
@pfm’s four-word verdict — “Buy the card not the grade wins once again” — collected 23 likes, the week’s highest single-post reaction. @fourthstartcg pushed back carefully, noting the frankenslabbed cards were likely altered to appear as strong 10s, not just pulled from the bulk bin. That nuance mattered. But the crowd had already made up its mind.
What PSA Owes You (Less Than You Think)
The fake slab thread kept producing story. By the final day of the week, @tcgmaine posted direct quotes from a PSA brand protection contact — vaulted cards do get inspected on arrival, the company said — and then the other shoe dropped: original submitters are not covered by PSA’s Grade Guarantee. Only buyers who purchased a card in a legitimate PSA holder qualify. Submit a card, get it graded, discover years later it was misgraded? You’re on your own. The forum’s proposed remedies ranged from free scanning services for pre-scan-era slabs (@gottaketchumall argued scanning — not reholdering — was the real play) to PSA imaging stations at card shows (@surfnsnow). @smpratte noted flatly that reholdering used to be a simple cosmetic swap before PSA changed ownership — no review, no downgrade risk. Those days are gone.
Sabrina Takes the Crown (Giovanni Settles for Silver)
Not everything this week was existential dread. @Littu’s multi-week Kanto gym leader elimination poll concluded on November 1 with Sabrina winning the whole thing, besting Giovanni for the top spot. The final ranking: Sabrina, Giovanni, Erika, Misty, Brock, Blaine, Lt. Surge, Koga. The forum largely agreed with the outcome, though the real discussion was about why — psychic being broken in Gen 1, Saffron City’s inaccessibility for most of the playthrough, and for some, a very memorable anime arc. @Silphnaut summarized that arc better than any poll could: Haunter mid-battle evolution, the dollhouse, Ash’s entire run to Saffron — “crazy story arc to 5 year old me.” The Johto bracket is apparently next. Whitney discourse incoming.
Forty-One Days of Scyther (And Counting)
Quietly, methodically, @doobdoesscyther has been running a daily Scyther collection series that hit Days 40 and 41 this week — Traditional Chinese and Simplified Chinese entries respectively, each with cultural context, language notes, and sourcing commentary. The series is winding toward its documented conclusion, after which a public-facing database with virtual binder functionality goes live. It’s one of the more ambitious collection documentation projects the forum has seen, and it keeps finding new things to say. This week’s Simplified Chinese note — that Scyther’s name starts with “飞” rather than “飛”, making the two variants distinguishable even without reading either language — is exactly the kind of detail that makes species collecting threads worth following. @xliveandplay, separately, completed a PSA 10 Zelda Gold Foil set from 2016 by landing the final G9 card. These things take years. Sometimes they finish.
HallowE4n, Reported
The forum did Halloween correctly. @gengarbrigade kicked off HallowE4n 2026 with a pair of photos that earned 20 likes before the thread was even formally open; @Parrotdox shared a Chandelure pumpkin carved by family; @caughtatpoint ran an actual Halloween-themed competitive deck at a league cup that day. @niece hosted a live Halloween event in Pokémon Tower — Edgar Allan Poe readings, a spooky DJ set, community storytelling — and documented the whole thing in real time. The QotD thread asking what you’d do as a new E4 mod ran alongside the festivities and generated its own entertainment: @ddk would ban anyone using multiple
emojis in a single post; @Will’s scheme involved an octagon, signed asset waivers, and a token for the “winner” who would also not be unbanned. The forum was, for one evening, in a good mood.
Dat’s da week, see — slabs, Sabrina, and somebody’s Scyther finally speakin’ Chinese. Meowth out.