BGS Lugia 1st edition Neo Genesis help needed (Authenticity and Cross over potential?)

Dear E4,

I have been lurking for many years on this awesome forum; such a great community and joy to read so many great informational posts and (old) topics. There is so much history!

I just finally decided to create an account, as I really hope you can help a fellow WOTC collector out.

I have the opportunity to purchase this Lugia (in person) for a realistic price comparable to last solds.

Since there is so much expertise available on this forum, I really hope anyone can help to check if this is the real deal. Until now all green flags, but hope you can help me out and confirm if this is the real thing?

The scratches are on the slab, not the card, according to the seller. But will see the card in person in a few days to double check.

  • Is this BGS Lugia real?
  • With subgrades 2x 9.0 and 2x 9.5, do you think it will cross over to a PSA 9 easily?

Hope you can help,

Looks real.

Can’t tell condition as you didn’t take pics of the back against a dark background.

The scratch looks like it’s on the slab.

Sadly BGS (and PSA even, really) with neo fan be somewhat all over the place.

A 9 surface can have no issues…or an 8.5 surface can have one minor print line. Or a 9 surface can have a major print line.

Same for PSA. Psa 9 examples can have very bad print lines, and PSA 8s can have none.

One of the BGS 10 examples with 9.5 surface has 3x quite large print lines.

It entirely depends on the card as opposed to it’s actual grade.

You need to assess it carefully and judge based on what you see in hand, and/or take more photos.

If you see multiple or deep print lines - no point trying to cross.

This was the cleanest example I ever graded (not my card sadly). I actually pre graded it a 9.

And here is my (different mon I know but same principal) T17. The surface has no issues but it has a 9 surface score :upside_down_face:

Tldr…what do you think based on your pics?

Wauw, thank you so much!

The corners do look very clean, but on the pictures there seems to be quite some scratches (on the slab?). Cant imagine BGS gives a 9.5 on surface if there would be so many scratches on the holo, but will see that in person in a few days.

I was hoping with 2x 9.5 and 2x 9.0 it would have a high chance of cross over to PSA 9. But that is a bit hit or miss? :pleading_face:

I added a few more picture of the back; it does look very clean to me?

Many thanks for your help!!

If the value is much higher in PSA 9, the person who has the BGS 9 copy likely would try and cross it to begin with. You could crack it out and try to re-grade it yourself, but it might come back a PSA 8 or it might get damaged in the process.

So I’d just buy the BGS 9 copy as-is, or pay extra for a PSA 9 instead of trying to do all the hard work that is more risky all around.

Ah I think OP hasn’t bought the card yet and is assessing a potential copy to purchase?

yes, indeed :star_struck:

In that case you need pics not against white background