1st edition Italian charizard ungraded

Hey looking to make an offer to someone. What would you value a lightly played 1st edition Italian charizard at? I can’t find anything but auctions as a reference.

Use the auction prices as a reference? That’s as close to market value as you’ll find. The Italian one is indeed one of the most expensive.

I recently sold a PSA 7 1st ed Italian Charizard on Ebay.ca for $400 Canadian. Hope that gives you a reference point.

I’m not using auctions that ended at $150 as a reference.

Thank you. It definitely helps a lot.